FirstHR

Interview Evaluation Form: 6 Free Templates

Free interview evaluation form templates for small businesses without HR: 6 versions with a 1-to-5 scale and scoring guidance. Download as DOCX.

TL;DR
An interview evaluation form, also called a feedback or assessment form, scores candidates on job-related criteria, often on a 1-to-5 scale, with evidence notes and a recommendation. Use the same form for every candidate. Under Equal Employment Opportunity Commission rules, employers with 15 or more employees must keep completed forms at least one year. Download all six templates as DOCX.
Category
Updated
Oct
16
2026
Reading time
14min

An interview evaluation form is a structured sheet an interviewer uses to score a candidate against job-related criteria and record why they would hire or pass. You will also see it called an interview feedback form, an interview assessment form, or a candidate evaluation form, which are the same document. It is the first hiring document I would hand another founder.

The reason is simple: the form makes hiring consistent and comparable across candidates, instead of leaving the decision to memory and to whoever made the best impression in the room. At FirstHR, we build for small businesses that hire without an HR team or an applicant tracking system, where the owner or office manager runs the interviews and the form is the only scoring system there is.

The six templates below cover the common situations: a general universal form, a plain-language small business version, a phone screen, a structured competency scorecard, a panel form, and a technical role-specific form. Each is ready to use, with the scoring and recordkeeping guidance generic forms skip.

Ryan Howard · First week
  • Sign the offer letter
  • Sign the employee handbook
  • Workplace Safety course
2/3
Onboarding
Run onboarding from one checklist
Tasks, documents to sign and courses for each new hire, sent with one launch.
Start free trial7-day free trial, no credit card

What an Interview Evaluation Form Is

An interview evaluation form is a structured document that rates a candidate's interview performance against a fixed set of job-related criteria, with a score and a note for each, and an overall recommendation at the end. It turns a conversation into a record you can compare against other candidates and defend later.

The same document goes by several names. Interview evaluation form, interview feedback form, interview assessment form, and candidate evaluation form are interchangeable. An interview scorecard is a closely related term for a version with defined competencies and rating anchors.

The form is filled out by the interviewer right after the interview, and it is the practical core of a structured interview, where every candidate is scored the same way.

What to Include

A complete evaluation form has four parts: header fields, job-related rating criteria, an evidence note under each, and a decision section. Getting all four right is what makes the form useful for comparing candidates and defensible as a hiring record.

Header fields
Candidate, position, and date
Interviewer name and interview type
Space for an overall recommendation
Rating criteria
A consistent 1-to-5 scale
Job-related criteria, the same for everyone
A score plus evidence for each
Evidence and notes
A note line under every criterion
Specific examples, not adjectives
Key strengths and key concerns
Decision and next steps
A total or overall score
A clear recommendation (hire / no hire)
Next steps and a signature

The mistake to avoid is skipping the evidence line and recording only a number, which makes the form impossible to compare or defend later. A score plus one specific observation is worth far more than a score alone.

Which Template Should You Use?

Pick the template by the stage and the role. The structure is similar across all of them, but each one fits a different point in the process or a different kind of interview. Use this guide to choose the closest fit, then adjust the criteria to your job.

General (Universal)· Any role
Six criteria, from relevant experience to motivation, each scored 1 to 5, with an overall recommendation at the end. The safe starting point for most roles.
Preview
Small Business (No HR)· Owner or manager
Plain questions such as “Can they do the actual job?” plus a short guide to deciding, written for an owner or office manager who runs the interviews.
Preview
Phone Screen· First call
Checks basic qualifications, availability, and pay expectations on the first call, then records one decision: advance to a full interview or not.
Preview
Structured / Competency· Behavioral anchors
The scorecard version: written 1-to-5 anchors for each competency, designed for answers in the STAR format (Situation, Task, Action, Result).
Preview
Panel· Multiple interviewers
Each interviewer scores on a separate sheet before anyone talks it over, then the group fills in a consensus block together.
Preview
Technical / Role-Specific· Custom hard skills
Swap in the hard skills the job depends on, whether you are hiring a developer or a retail or service worker, and keep the general criteria next to them.
Preview
Tip
Match the Form to the Stage
First call: Phone Screen. A general role: General (Universal). An owner interviewing without HR: Small Business. Competency-based scoring with anchors: Structured / Competency. Several interviewers: Panel. A role with specific hard skills: Technical / Role-Specific. Whatever you pick, use the same form and scale for every candidate for that role, so the comparison is fair.
See who is on track and who is stuck
Active Onboardings lists every new hire in progress. Late items are marked, so you see them without messaging anyone.

6 Free Interview Evaluation Form Templates

Download all six as separate Word files in one ZIP, or copy individual forms. Each follows the same structure: header fields, job-related criteria on a 1-to-5 scale, evidence notes, and a decision section. Fill in the blanks and use the same form for every candidate.

Download All 6 Templates
General, small business, phone screen, structured, panel, and technical. All as DOCX files in one ZIP.

Template 1: General Interview Evaluation Form (Universal)

The default form: experience, skills, communication, problem-solving, teamwork, and motivation on a 1-to-5 scale, with an overall recommendation. Start here for most roles.

General Interview Evaluation Form (Universal)
GENERAL INTERVIEW EVALUATION FORM
Candidate:
Position:
Interview date:
Interviewer:
Interview type: [ ] Phone [ ] Video [ ] In-person
Rate each area from 1 (poor) to 5 (excellent). Add a short note with
evidence from the interview, not just an impression.

EVALUATION CRITERIA

Relevant experience Score: [ 1 2 3 4 5 ]
Notes:
Job and technical skills Score: [ 1 2 3 4 5 ]
Notes:
Communication Score: [ 1 2 3 4 5 ]
Notes:
Problem-solving Score: [ 1 2 3 4 5 ]
Notes:
Teamwork and interpersonal Score: [ 1 2 3 4 5 ]
Notes:
Motivation and culture add Score: [ 1 2 3 4 5 ]
Notes:

SUMMARY

Total score: ______ / 30
Overall recommendation: [ ] Strong hire [ ] Hire [ ] Maybe [ ] No hire
Key strengths:
Key concerns:
Next steps:
Interviewer signature:

Template 2: Small Business Interview Evaluation Form (No HR / No ATS)

A plain-language version for a founder or office manager interviewing without HR, with a built-in how-to-decide guide. The version generic templates skip.

Small Business Interview Evaluation Form (No HR / No ATS)
SMALL BUSINESS INTERVIEW EVALUATION FORM
(Plain-language version for an owner or manager interviewing without HR)
Candidate:
Position:
Interview date:
Interviewer:
Score 1 to 5, where 1 is "this worries me" and 5 is "exactly what we need."
Write one line of evidence for each, so you can compare candidates later.

WHAT TO RATE

Can they do the actual job? Score: [ 1 2 3 4 5 ]
Evidence:
Have they done something like this? Score: [ 1 2 3 4 5 ]
Evidence:
Will they communicate clearly? Score: [ 1 2 3 4 5 ]
Evidence:
Will they fit how the team works? Score: [ 1 2 3 4 5 ]
Evidence:
Are they reliable and motivated? Score: [ 1 2 3 4 5 ]
Evidence:

HOW TO DECIDE

Add the scores. Compare candidates on the numbers AND the evidence, not on who
you liked most in the room, since the most likeable candidate is not always the
best hire. A candidate who scores well with specific evidence beats one who
scored well on impression alone.
Total: ______ / 25
Decision: [ ] Move forward [ ] Second interview [ ] Pass
One-line reason:
Interviewer:

Template 3: Phone Screen / Initial Screening Evaluation Form

A short form for the first call: basic qualifications, availability, compensation expectations, and a simple advance-or-not decision.

Phone Screen / Initial Screening Evaluation Form
PHONE SCREEN EVALUATION FORM
Candidate:
Position:
Screen date:
Screened by:
A short form for the first call, to decide who advances to a full interview.

SCREENING CRITERIA

Meets basic qualifications [ ] Yes [ ] No [ ] Partial
Relevant experience Score: [ 1 2 3 4 5 ]
Communication on the call Score: [ 1 2 3 4 5 ]
Interest and motivation Score: [ 1 2 3 4 5 ]
Availability / start date:
Compensation expectations:
Work authorization confirmed: [ ] Yes [ ] Not yet
Location / schedule fit:

DECISION

Advance to full interview: [ ] Yes [ ] No [ ] Maybe
Notes:
Screened by:

Template 4: Structured Competency Scoring Form (Behavioral Anchors)

A scoring form with defined 1-to-5 anchors per competency, built for STAR-based answers. Captures the interview scorecard use case.

Structured Competency Scoring Form (Behavioral Anchors)
STRUCTURED COMPETENCY INTERVIEW SCORING FORM
Candidate:
Position:
Interview date:
Interviewer:
Score each competency 1 to 5 using the anchors below. Score from the evidence
in the candidate's answers, ideally using STAR (Situation, Task, Action,
Result).
Anchors:
1 = No evidence or a concerning answer
2 = Below the bar; thin or generic
3 = Meets the bar; solid, relevant example
4 = Above the bar; strong, specific, measurable
5 = Exceptional; clear, repeatable, high-impact

COMPETENCIES

Competency 1: Score: [ 1 2 3 4 5 ]
Evidence:
Competency 2: Score: [ 1 2 3 4 5 ]
Evidence:
Competency 3: Score: [ 1 2 3 4 5 ]
Evidence:
Competency 4: Score: [ 1 2 3 4 5 ]
Evidence:
Competency 5: Score: [ 1 2 3 4 5 ]
Evidence:

SUMMARY

Total / weighted score:
Overall: [ ] Strong yes [ ] Yes [ ] No [ ] Strong no
Interviewer signature:

Template 5: Panel Interview Evaluation Form (Multi-Interviewer)

One sheet per interviewer plus a consensus block, with independent scoring before discussion so no single voice anchors the group.

Panel Interview Evaluation Form (Multi-Interviewer)
PANEL INTERVIEW EVALUATION FORM
Candidate:
Position:
Interview date:
Each panel member fills out their own copy and scores independently BEFORE the
group discusses, so strong opinions do not anchor everyone else.

INDIVIDUAL INTERVIEWER (one per panel member)

Interviewer name:
Area of focus: (e.g., technical, culture, leadership)
Experience and skills Score: [ 1 2 3 4 5 ]
Communication Score: [ 1 2 3 4 5 ]
Problem-solving Score: [ 1 2 3 4 5 ]
Team and culture add Score: [ 1 2 3 4 5 ]
Recommendation: [ ] Strong yes [ ] Yes [ ] No [ ] Strong no
Evidence and notes:
Signature:

CONSENSUS (filled in together after independent scores)

Average score:
Points of agreement:
Points of disagreement:
Final decision: [ ] Offer [ ] Next round [ ] Pass
Decision owner:

Template 6: Technical / Role-Specific Interview Evaluation Form

Customizable skill rows for any role, from a developer to a retail or service hire, alongside the general criteria.

Technical / Role-Specific Interview Evaluation Form
TECHNICAL / ROLE-SPECIFIC INTERVIEW EVALUATION FORM
Candidate:
Position:
Interview date:
Interviewer:
Replace the skill rows below with the specific hard skills your role requires
(for example: a coding language, equipment, a process, a software tool, a sales
or service skill).

ROLE-SPECIFIC SKILLS

Skill 1: Score: [ 1 2 3 4 5 ]
Notes:
Skill 2: Score: [ 1 2 3 4 5 ]
Notes:
Skill 3: Score: [ 1 2 3 4 5 ]
Notes:
Skill 4: Score: [ 1 2 3 4 5 ]
Notes:

GENERAL CRITERIA

Communication Score: [ 1 2 3 4 5 ]
Problem-solving Score: [ 1 2 3 4 5 ]
Team and culture add Score: [ 1 2 3 4 5 ]

SUMMARY

Total score:
Overall recommendation: [ ] Strong hire [ ] Hire [ ] Maybe [ ] No hire
Interviewer signature:

Fair, Consistent, and Compliant Scoring

Fair, consistent, and compliant scoring comes down to four habits: keep the criteria job-related, score every candidate the same way, write evidence instead of opinions, and keep the completed forms. Generic forms skip this part, yet it is what makes an evaluation form an asset rather than a liability. None of it is complicated, and all of it produces better hires.

Job-related only
Score the job, not the person
An interview evaluation form is a written record of a hiring decision, so it has to stay job-related. Score only criteria tied to the role, such as relevant experience, skills, communication, and problem-solving, and never record anything connected to a protected characteristic. Federal anti-discrimination laws, enforced by the U.S. Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC), prohibit basing hiring decisions on race, color, religion, sex (including transgender status, sexual orientation, and pregnancy), national origin, age (40 or older), disability, or genetic information. A form that captures notes about any of those becomes evidence against the employer rather than for it. Keep the criteria, and every note, focused on the ability to do the job. The forms here are built to keep scoring on the role. This is general information, not legal advice.
Consistency
Use the same form and scale for every candidate
The single most valuable habit is consistency: use the same form, the same criteria, and the same 1-to-5 scale for every candidate for a role. According to the U.S. Office of Personnel Management’s structured interview guide (2008), structured interviews show a high degree of reliability, validity, and legal defensibility, while unstructured interviews have little value in predicting job performance. Consistency is what makes a form defensible against a claim of unfair treatment, because every candidate was measured the same way. This matters most for a small business without HR, where it is tempting to rate each candidate ad hoc. Decide the criteria before the first interview, score each candidate against them, and keep the completed forms. This is general information, not legal advice.
Documentation
Write evidence, not opinions
The notes section is where evaluation forms go wrong. A note like “good culture fit” is vague and, worse, can be a place where bias hides, since “culture fit” is often code for someone the interviewer simply liked. Replace it with specific evidence: what the candidate said or did that supports the score. Strong notes quote a real answer or describe a concrete example. This makes the form more useful for comparing candidates, and it keeps the record defensible by tying each score to observable behavior rather than a gut feeling about the person.
Record keeping
Keep completed forms on file
Each completed form is a hiring record, and federal rules require keeping it once a business has 15 or more employees. Under the EEOC’s recordkeeping regulation, those employers must preserve personnel and employment records, including application forms and other records related to hiring, for at least one year after the record was made or the personnel action (such as the hiring decision) was taken, whichever is later. The period extends to two years for educational institutions and state and local governments. If a discrimination charge is filed, keep the records until the matter is finally resolved. Store completed forms with the candidate or new-hire record. This is general information, not legal advice.
By the numbers
Employers With 15 or More Employees Must Keep Hiring Records at Least One Year
Completed evaluation forms are hiring records. Under the EEOC's recordkeeping rules (29 CFR Part 1602), employers with 15 or more employees must keep personnel and employment records related to hiring for at least one year, and educational institutions and state and local governments must keep them for two years. If a discrimination charge is filed, keep the records until it is resolved.

Larger federal contractors must keep hiring records longer. The Labor Department's Section 503 recordkeeping regulation, part of its disability nondiscrimination rules for federal contractors, sets two years for a contractor with at least 150 employees and a government contract of at least $150,000. It also lists interview notes among the records to keep.

Beyond recordkeeping, job-related criteria also keep you within the rules: the federal laws the EEOC enforces prohibit basing hiring decisions on protected characteristics, so a form that scores only role-related criteria protects the business as well as the candidate. This is general information, not legal advice.

How to Use the Form

Using the form well is mostly about timing and consistency. Set the criteria first, score right after the interview, write evidence, then compare on the numbers. The steps below work for a single interviewer or a panel.

1
Set criteria
Decide the job-related criteria before the first interview
2
Score promptly
Fill out the form right after each interview, 1 to 5 per criterion
3
Add evidence
Write a specific note under each score, not an adjective
4
Total and recommend
Add the scores and record a clear hire or no-hire recommendation
5
Compare candidates
Lay the forms side by side; score independently first on a panel
6
Store the form
Keep the completed form on file; the one-year retention rule applies at 15 or more employees

Score immediately while the interview is fresh, and on a panel have each person score before the group discusses, so a single strong opinion does not anchor everyone else. The structured interview guide from the U.S. Office of Personnel Management (2008) gives the same advice: rate right after the candidate leaves, and on a panel, rate independently before anyone compares notes.

Onboarding Templates
Sales Associate11 steps
Warehouse Foreman10 steps
Customer Service12 steps
Onboarding
Each new hire, set up in one go
Put tasks, documents to sign and courses into one plan, then send all of it with one launch.

How to turn the form into a hiring rubric

A hiring rubric is the evaluation form plus a written definition of what each score means, so two people rating the same answer land on the same number. Without those anchors, a 3 from one interviewer is a 5 from another and the totals stop being comparable.

ScoreWhat it meansWhat the note should show
1No evidence, or an answer that raises a concernWhat was missing, or what worried you
2Below the bar: thin, generic, or secondhandThe vague part of the answer, paraphrased
3Meets the bar: a solid, relevant exampleThe example itself, in one line
4Above the bar: specific, with a measurable resultThe number or outcome the candidate gave
5Exceptional: clear, repeatable, high impactThe result, plus what they would repeat or change

Write the anchors before the first interview and hand them to anyone else who interviews. The structured competency form above already ships with this scale, so the fastest route to a rubric is to use that version and fill in the five competencies the role actually needs.

Pairing the form with an interview guide

An interview guide is a single sheet that holds the questions and the evaluation form together, so the interviewer asks, takes notes, and scores in one place instead of juggling three documents. For a manager interviewing without HR, that one page is the whole system.

Build it in the order the interview runs: a two-line opening, the same questions for every candidate with note space under each, then the scoring block from the form, then the closing and next steps. Notes go in during the conversation, scores go in right after it ends.

The questions themselves come from the role. Our behavioral interview questions supply the question half of the guide, and the guide to conducting an interview covers the timing around it.

Evaluating Candidates Without HR

At a large company, an applicant tracking system (ATS) collects structured scorecards automatically. At a small business there is no ATS, so the evaluation form is the entire scoring system, and a single gut-feel hire is costly at that size. Here is how to make it work without the software.

There is no ATS scoring candidates for you, so the form is the system
The owner or office manager runs the interviews and, without a written evaluation, has only memory to go on. The forms above are a scoring system in its simplest form. Pick the version that matches the role, score each candidate on the same criteria, and keep the completed sheets. That turns a stack of half-remembered conversations into a side-by-side comparison you can actually decide from.
Without a form, the most likeable candidate wins, not the best one
When there is no structure, hiring drifts toward whoever made the best impression in the room, which is exactly how bias creeps in and how strong-on-paper candidates get passed over for charismatic ones. According to Harvard Business Review (2016), hiring managers consistently give unstructured interviews the highest ratings for perceived effectiveness, even though dozens of studies find them among the worst predictors of on-the-job performance. A simple evaluation form fixes this by forcing a score and a piece of evidence for each job-related criterion, the same for every candidate. The likeable candidate still scores well on communication, but now they have to earn the experience and skills scores too, on the record.
The form is the last step before the part FirstHR actually automates
An interview evaluation form is a pre-hire document, but it sits one step before the moment a small business needs the most help: turning a chosen candidate into an onboarded employee. Once the form points to a hire, the work becomes the offer, the paperwork, and a structured first week. FirstHR fits that next step for a small business: send the offer for e-signature, run the new hire paperwork and onboarding workflow, and store the completed evaluation alongside the new employee’s record. To be clear on scope, FirstHR is an onboarding and HR platform, not an applicant tracking system, so the form lives here and the hire flows into FirstHR. Applicant tracking is coming soon.

From Evaluation to Hire

The form is the decision tool; the hire is what comes next. Once the completed forms point to a candidate, the process shifts to making the offer, running the paperwork, and onboarding, the part a small business most needs to get right and the part FirstHR is built for.

1
Score every candidate
Use the same form and 1-to-5 scale for everyone, with a score and a line of evidence for each criterion.
2
Compare on the numbers
Decide from the totals and the evidence side by side, not from who interviewed most smoothly.
3
Send the offer
Once you choose, confirm the role, pay, and start date in writing, with e-signature for a clean record.
4
Onboard and store the form
Move the new hire into onboarding and keep the completed evaluation on their record to meet any retention rule that applies.

Once your evaluations point to a hire, the offer letter template handles the next step, and an onboarding template gives the new hire a structured start. FirstHR connects the offer, paperwork, e-signatures, and onboarding workflow in one place, and stores the completed evaluation on the new employee's record, so a small business can run everything from the offer through onboarding in one system.

FirstHR is an onboarding and HR platform, not an applicant tracking system, so the evaluation form lives here and the hire flows into onboarding. Applicant tracking is coming soon to FirstHR.

Set up your next new hire in FirstHR
4.7 on G2
Offer LetterSigned
Welcome courseCompleted
Key takeaways
1An interview evaluation form scores a candidate against job-related criteria; evaluation form, feedback form, and assessment form all name the same document.
2Use the version that fits: general, small business, phone screen, structured, panel, or technical.
3A complete form has header fields, job-related criteria on a consistent 1-to-5 scale, evidence notes, and a decision.
4Use the same form and scale for every candidate, and score from evidence rather than overall impression.
5Keep the criteria job-related to stay fair and compliant, and write specific evidence instead of vague culture-fit notes.
6Completed forms are hiring records: employers with 15 or more employees must keep them at least one year under EEOC rules, and some employers two years.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is an interview evaluation form?

An interview evaluation form is a structured document an interviewer uses to score and record how a candidate performed against a set of job-related criteria. Other names for it include candidate evaluation form, interview assessment form, and interview feedback form, and all of them refer to the same artifact. A typical form captures the candidate name, position, date, and interviewer, then rates criteria such as relevant experience, skills, communication, problem-solving, teamwork, and motivation, often on a 1-to-5 scale, with an evidence note under each one and a final recommendation. Its purpose is to make hiring decisions consistent and comparable across candidates rather than based on memory or impression, and to create a written record of why a candidate was hired or passed over.

What is the difference between an interview evaluation form and a scorecard?

They are largely the same tool, with a difference in emphasis. Interview evaluation form is the broad term: it covers any structured sheet used to rate a candidate after an interview, whether your team calls it a feedback form or an assessment form. An interview scorecard usually refers to a more tightly defined version that scores specific competencies on a rating scale, often with behavioral anchors that describe what each score looks like. In practice the words are used interchangeably, and a good evaluation form is a scorecard: it defines the criteria, applies a consistent scale, and asks for evidence. The structured competency version on this page is the scorecard-style form, while the general version is the broader evaluation form. Pick whichever framing fits how your team talks about hiring.

What should be included in an interview evaluation form?

A complete interview evaluation form has four parts. First, header fields: candidate name, position, interview date, interviewer, and interview type. Second, rating criteria tied to the job, such as relevant experience, technical or job skills, communication, problem-solving, teamwork, and motivation, each scored on a consistent scale. Third, a note or evidence line under each criterion so the score is backed by something specific the candidate said or did. Fourth, a summary: a total or overall score, a clear recommendation such as strong hire, hire, maybe, or no hire, key strengths and concerns, next steps, and a signature. Keeping every criterion job-related and asking for evidence is what lets the form compare candidates fairly and hold up later as a hiring record.

What rating scale should an interview evaluation form use?

A 1-to-5 scale is a common choice and works well for most teams. It is granular enough to separate candidates but simple enough to apply consistently, typically running from 1 (poor or unsatisfactory) to 5 (excellent or exceptional), with 3 as meets expectations. It also sits within the range the U.S. Office of Personnel Management recommends in its 2008 guide to structured interviews: at least 3 proficiency levels, ideally 5 to 7. Some teams prefer a 4-point scale such as poor, fair, good, and great, which removes the neutral middle and forces a clearer judgment, or a recommendation scale like strong no, no, yes, strong yes. The exact scale matters less than using the same one for every candidate and defining what each level means, ideally with a short anchor. The structured form on this page includes behavioral anchors for each score so different interviewers rate consistently. Whatever scale you choose, apply it the same way across all candidates.

How do you evaluate a candidate after an interview?

Fill out the evaluation form immediately after the interview, while the answers are fresh, and score from evidence rather than overall impression. Go criterion by criterion: for each one, recall what the candidate actually said or did, assign a score on your scale, and write a short note capturing the evidence. Resist the pull to let one strong or weak moment color every score, which is a common bias. Then total the scores, weigh the strengths against the concerns, and record a clear recommendation. If multiple people interviewed, have each score independently before comparing, so no single opinion anchors the group. Finally, keep the completed form on file. This evidence-based, consistent approach produces better hires than deciding from a general feeling about the candidate. This is general information, not legal advice.

Are interview evaluation forms legally required to keep?

Yes, once a business has 15 or more employees. The Equal Employment Opportunity Commission’s recordkeeping regulation, 29 CFR Part 1602, binds every employer covered by Title VII of the Civil Rights Act, the Americans with Disabilities Act, the Genetic Information Nondiscrimination Act, and the Pregnant Workers Fairness Act. Those employers have to hold on to any personnel or employment record tied to hiring, including application and evaluation forms for rejected candidates as well as new hires. The minimum is one year, counted from whichever is later: the day the record was created or the day the hiring decision was made. State and local governments and educational institutions must keep the same records for two years. Federal contractors also answer to the Labor Department’s Section 503 regulation on disability nondiscrimination: two years for a contractor that employs 150 or more people and holds a government contract worth $150,000 or more, one year for any other contractor. If a candidate files a discrimination charge, keep the related records until the matter is finally resolved. Smaller employers should still look up their state’s retention rules. This is general information, not legal advice.

How can a small business use an interview evaluation form without an ATS?

The form is the system when you do not have an applicant tracking system. Choose the version that fits the role, settle on the criteria before the first interview, and score every candidate on the same form and scale, with a line of evidence for each. After the interviews, lay the completed forms side by side and compare on the scores and the evidence rather than on who you liked most. Keep the completed forms on file, which the EEOC recordkeeping rule requires once you have 15 or more employees. This gives a small business the structure an ATS would provide, at no cost and with no software, and it directly reduces the chance of a biased or purely gut-feel hire. When you choose someone, move them into onboarding. This is general information, not legal advice.

What is the difference between an interview evaluation form and an interview feedback form?

There is no meaningful difference; they are two names for the same document. Whether you call it an interview feedback form, a candidate evaluation form, an interview assessment form, or an interview evaluation form, it is a structured sheet used to rate and record a candidate’s interview performance against job-related criteria. The word feedback sometimes implies the notes will be shared, either with other interviewers to reach a decision or, less commonly, with the candidate, but the form itself is the same. Whichever term your team uses, the essentials are identical: consistent job-related criteria, a rating scale, evidence notes, and an overall recommendation. The templates on this page serve all of these names.

Make HR the easy part of running your business

Onboarding, e-signatures, training and core HR in one place. Up and running in 5 minutes.

  • 7-day free trial
  • No credit card required
  • Cancel anytime
4.7 on G2300+ companies trust FirstHR