FirstHR

Vermont Payroll: Employer Tax and Software Guide

Vermont payroll for employers: graduated withholding, the $15,400 unemployment wage base, the 0.44 percent child care tax, and 10 providers compared.

TL;DR
Vermont withholds income tax at four graduated rates, 3.35 to 8.75 percent, using Form W-4VT. Employers pay unemployment tax on each worker's first $15,400, a 0.44 percent child care tax, and a quarterly health care assessment per uncovered full-time equivalent beyond four. Minimum wage is $14.42; pay is weekly by default. Patriot costs least; OnPay adds no multi-state surcharge.
Category
Updated
Oct
10
2026
Reading time
16min

Vermont is a small state that files like a big one. If another founder asked me where to start with payroll here, I would say: learn the state's rules before you compare software prices. This guide follows that order: what Vermont requires of employers, then how 10 payroll providers compare, priced at 10, 25, and 50 employees where rates are published.

One quarterly return carries three separate taxes with three different bases, and one of those three is not a percentage of wages at all. It is a headcount charge measured in full-time equivalents. The income tax withholding on that return is graduated, not flat, and the child care payroll tax shares the form but has its own base and its own employee deduction rules.

That headcount charge is a health care assessment: it counts uncovered employees, requires a signed declaration from each of them every year, and bills you for the ones who never returned the form. Unemployment contributions stop at a capped wage base that most full-time employees cross partway through the year. And unless you have given your staff notice of another schedule, state law says you pay them every week.

None of this is exotic. It is just four systems that do not line up, run by a business that in most cases has no full-time payroll person. The next sections take them one at a time, then turn to the obligations that opening a withholding account does not hand you.

My TeamPam BeeslyFull-timeJim HalpertFull-timeRyan HowardPart-time
Core HR
Your team's records in one place
A profile and documents for each person, and the org chart built from them.
Start free trial7-day free trial, no credit card

What Vermont requires from employers

Four state obligations sit on top of federal payroll: income tax withholding, unemployment insurance contributions, the Child Care Contribution, and the Health Care Fund Contribution Assessment. Three of the four are reported on the same quarterly form, which is why employers so often assume they are the same tax.

State income tax withholding

Vermont taxes wage income on a graduated schedule. The four marginal rates are 3.35 percent, 6.60 percent, 7.60 percent, and 8.75 percent, and there is no city, town, or county income tax anywhere in the state to layer on top.

Withholding is not a percentage of gross pay. The employer subtracts the employee's allowances from wages for the period, then reads the rate table for that filing status and pay frequency. Those tables live in GB-1210 (full title: Income Tax Withholding Instructions, Tables, and Charts), which the Vermont Department of Taxes reissues each January because the bracket thresholds are reset annually.

The withholding allowance resets with the tables: in the 2026 edition, one annual allowance is worth $5,400. Allowances, filing status, and any extra per-period amount all come from Form W-4VT, the Vermont Employee's Withholding Allowance Certificate, which is a separate document from the federal Form W-4.

Warning
Extra federal withholding converts to Vermont at 30 percent
Vermont publishes an unusual conversion rule. Where an employee has asked for an additional amount of federal withholding each pay period on the federal W-4 and has not filed a W-4VT, Vermont withholding should be increased by 30 percent of that extra federal amount, not by the full amount. Payroll systems that mirror the federal extra-withholding field straight into the state field will over-withhold Vermont tax substantially. Get a W-4VT on file and put the intended Vermont amount there instead, where it is applied directly.

Deposit schedules and returns

Vermont largely avoids inventing its own deposit tiers. Payment frequency generally mirrors the federal frequency: an employer required to deposit federal withholding semiweekly deposits Vermont withholding semiweekly, and the same for monthly and quarterly.

Payment frequencyWhen Vermont withholding is dueQuarterly returnAnnual reconciliation
SemiweeklyWednesday, Thursday, Friday pay dates due the following Wednesday; all other pay dates due the following FridayWHT-436WHT-434
MonthlyBy the 25th of the following month; January is due February 23WHT-436WHT-434
QuarterlyPaid with the quarterly returnWHT-436WHT-434
All filersQuarterly reconciliation filed at the close of every quarterWHT-436WHT-434 due the last day of January

Every filer, regardless of deposit frequency, files Form WHT-436 at the close of each quarter and Form WHT-434 by the last day of January. Any employer submitting 10 or more W-2 or 1099 forms must file electronically, a threshold the Social Security Administration lowered from 25 and which now captures most Vermont employers with more than a handful of staff.

Unemployment insurance contributions

Unemployment insurance is an employer-only cost in Vermont; nothing comes out of the employee. The taxable wage base rose to $15,400 for 2026 from $14,800, an increase of $600 that the Department of Labor announced in an October 2025 release.

Because the base is capped, so is the annual cost per head: at the 1 percent new employer rate that is $154 per employee per year, and even the highest rate in the highest schedule tops out at about $1,294.

The cap also shapes when you pay. An employee earning about $61,600 a year clears the base by the end of the first quarter, while a full-time employee at the $14.42 minimum wage needs close to 27 weeks to get there. Budget accordingly: the contributions are front-loaded for your highest earners and spread across half the year for everyone else.

Most new employers pay 1 percent. The exception is an out-of-state construction corporation, classified under North American Industry Classification System (NAICS) codes 236, 237, or 238 (building, heavy and civil engineering, and specialty trade construction). It is assigned a rate based on the industry average instead.

Experience rating takes time to arrive: the law requires at least one complete calendar year of benefit liability, and because rates are recalculated only annually, most employers stay at the new employer rate for at least two years. When experience rating does apply, your rate comes from the statutory schedules below.

Rate scheduleLowest rate, class 0Highest rate, class 20Relative funding level
Schedule 10.4%5.4%Below equilibrium
Schedule 20.6%5.9%Below equilibrium
Schedule 30.8%6.5%Equilibrium across the business cycle
Schedule 41.1%7.7%Above equilibrium
Schedule 51.3%8.4%Above equilibrium

Section 1326 of the Vermont Unemployment Compensation Law provides those five schedules, each holding 21 tax rates, and a statutory formula picks which one is in effect. Your class within the schedule comes from a benefit ratio: the Vermont Department of Labor divides benefits charged to your record over the last one to three calendar years by the taxable wages you reported for the same period. Class 0 is reserved for employers with no benefits charged at all.

One scheduling detail matters for budgeting. Contribution rates run on a July to June year while the wage base changes on January 1, so a Vermont employer sees two separate changes to the same tax in the same twelve months. Federal unemployment tax runs alongside on the first $7,000 of wages, and paying state contributions on time is what keeps the federal rate at the reduced level.

The Child Care Contribution

Act 76 of 2023 created a 0.44 percent payroll tax on Vermont wages, effective for wages paid on or after July 1, 2024, to fund the state child care system. According to the Vermont Child Care Contribution guidance, the employer owes the whole 0.44 percent and may elect to recover up to one quarter of it, meaning not more than 0.11 percent of any employee's wages, by deduction.

Take the maximum deduction and the split lands at 0.11 percent from the employee and 0.33 percent from the employer. Take nothing and the employer carries the whole 0.44 percent. Anything in between is allowed, and the election is made per employee rather than company-wide, so an employer may deduct from some people and not others.

Two details get missed. Anything withheld is reported in Box 14 of that employee's W-2, which means the deduction election has a year-end consequence as well as a per-run one.

The second detail is the base, which is narrower than your total payroll: only wages subject to Vermont income tax withholding are subject to the contribution, so wages for work physically performed outside Vermont are excluded even when an out-of-state employer voluntarily withholds Vermont tax as a courtesy to a resident employee.

Everyone in one list, with who they report to
Position, department, type, manager and status for each person. People who have left move to a separate list.

The local layer that state registration does not cover

Vermont has no municipal payroll taxes and no local income tax, so employers reasonably assume that a withholding account and an unemployment account finish the job. They do not. Four obligations sit outside those two registrations, and three of them are documentation problems rather than calculation problems.

The health care assessment counts people, not dollars

The Health Care Fund Contribution Assessment is charged per uncovered full-time equivalent employee, per quarter. The arithmetic, set out in the Vermont statutes at 32 V.S.A. section 10504, is unlike anything else in a payroll run.

Start by totaling the hours worked by all uncovered employees during the quarter, capping any single individual at 520 hours no matter how much they actually worked. Divide that total by 520, round down, then subtract four. The first four uncovered full-time equivalents are exempt for every employer.

The rate per remaining uncovered full-time equivalent changes every year, adjusted to match the change in premiums for the second-lowest-cost silver-level plan on the Vermont Health Benefit Exchange. Because it tracks insurance pricing rather than an inflation index, it moves upward with health costs. Confirm the current quarterly rate on the HC-1 worksheet before each filing rather than carrying last year's number forward.

FormPurposeWho completes itWhere it goes
HC-2Declaration of Health Care CoverageEach uncovered employee, annuallyRetained by the employer for three years
HC-1Assessment worksheetEmployer, each quarterRetained by the employer for three years
WHT-436 Part IVReports and pays the assessmentEmployer, each quarterFiled and paid electronically with the state
WHT-436 Line 10Fewer than five full-time equivalents over 18Employer, each quarterBox checked, zero return still filed
Warning
A missing HC-2 is treated as no coverage
Where an employee is not covered by the employer plan and no HC-2 is on file for them, the law requires that employee to be treated as uncovered, and on audit the Department of Taxes is required to assess for them. An employer can end up paying for someone who was insured through a spouse the entire time, purely because the form was never collected. New declarations are required every year and again whenever coverage changes, which makes this a recurring document-collection task rather than a one-time onboarding step. Deducting any part of the assessment from an employee's pay is illegal.

Earned sick time accrues at a rate nobody guesses correctly

Under 21 V.S.A. section 482, Vermont requires earned sick time at not less than one hour for every 52 hours worked, a slower accrual than the one-per-30 rate several other states use. An employer may cap accrual at 40 hours in a 12-month period and may impose a waiting period of up to one year for new hires, during which time still accrues but cannot be used.

Coverage is defined by hours, not headcount. The law defines a covered employee as someone employed for an average of no less than 18 hours per week during a year, and the carve-outs are narrower than employers assume.

Those carve-outs include people under 18, someone employed 20 weeks or fewer in a 12-month period who is also in a job scheduled to last 20 weeks or fewer, and health care facility staff who work only on a per diem or intermittent basis.

Earned sick time is paid at the greater of the employee's normal hourly rate or the state minimum wage, and accrual must be calculated either each pay period or quarterly.

Weekly pay is the default, not the option

Under 21 V.S.A. section 342, an employer doing business in Vermont pays each employee every week, for wages earned to a day not more than six days before the payment date. Biweekly and semimonthly are permitted, but only after giving notice to each employee, and the six-day lag still applies. A collective bargaining agreement can extend the lag to 13 days.

SituationVermont requirementPractical effect on payroll
Default scheduleWeekly, wages earned to within six days of paymentNotice to each employee required to move to biweekly or semimonthly
Employee is dischargedPaid within 72 hours of dischargeOften forces an off-cycle payroll run
Employee quitsLast regular pay day, or the following Friday if there is noneHandled in the normal cycle
Employee absent on paydayPayment upon demandCannot be deferred to the next batch
Direct deposit or pay cardWritten authorization from the employeePay cards carry extra disclosure and free-withdrawal rules

The 72-hour discharge rule is the one that costs money. It does not wait for your cycle, and a provider that charges per off-cycle run or needs two business days to originate a direct deposit will turn a routine termination into either a fee or a violation. Ask about off-cycle runs before you sign, not after your first firing.

The border is a payroll question

Vermont borders three states with entirely different payroll mechanics, and small Vermont employers cross those lines constantly. An out-of-state employer is not required to begin withholding Vermont income tax until an employee has been working from a Vermont location for thirty days.

The thirty-day threshold is about when the employer must withhold, not about what the employee owes. An employee who lives and works remotely in Vermont is taxable on income earned during the entire period they live there, even if they claim another state as their domicile (their permanent legal home).

For nonresidents who split a pay period between Vermont and elsewhere, the tax is computed on the full payment and then multiplied by the ratio of Vermont hours to total hours. For Vermont residents paid for services performed in another state, withholding is computed on the full payment and then reduced by the tax withheld for that other state.

Minimum wage, by contrast, is where Vermont is refreshingly simple: there are no local minimum wage ordinances to track. The rate is $14.42 per hour as of January 1, 2026, up from $14.01, with a basic tipped wage of $7.21, exactly half the full minimum.

Vermont indexes the rate under 21 V.S.A. section 384: it rises each January by the smaller of five percent or the change in the Consumer Price Index for all urban consumers over the 12 months preceding the previous September 1, rounded to the nearest cent, and it can never fall.

The tipped rate applies to service employees of hotels, motels, tourist places, and restaurants who customarily receive more than $120 a month in tips, with the employer covering any shortfall.

Registration and the rest of the setup

A Vermont employer opens a business tax account with the Department of Taxes for withholding, and a separate unemployment insurance account with the Department of Labor for quarterly wage and contribution reporting. The Child Care Contribution and the health care assessment do not require their own registrations; they attach to the withholding account and appear on Form WHT-436. New hires are reported to the state directory, and workers compensation coverage is required.

10 payroll providers for Vermont employers compared

Every provider below files Vermont income tax withholding and unemployment contributions on its full-service plans. The real differences for Vermont payroll services are whether the platform populates the Child Care Contribution and health care assessment lines on Form WHT-436 without manual entry, how it handles off-cycle runs for the 72-hour discharge rule, and what a second state costs.

ProviderBest ForStarting PricePricing ModelVT Tax FilingMulti-State IncludedBenefits AdminTrial
OnPaySingle-plan pricing, no tiers$49 + $6/eeBase + PEPM1 month
GustoFirst-time payroll buyers$49 + $6/eeBase + PEPMUntil 1st run
PatriotLowest cost, tight budgets$37 + $5/eeBase + PEPM30 days
SurePayrollVery small and household teams$29 + $7/eeBase + PEPMVaries
QuickBooksExisting QuickBooks accounting$50 + $7/eeBase + PEPM30 days
ADP RUNCompliance depth at scaleQuoteQuoteVaries
Paychex FlexHands-on service modelQuoteQuoteVaries
PaylocityGrowing teams wanting HR depthQuoteQuoteDemo
RipplingPayroll tied to HR and IT$40 + $8/userModular PEPMDemo
JustworksBenefits through a PEO$50 + $8/eeBase + PEPMDemo
Published vendor rates as of October 2026. PEPM = per employee per month. ADP RUN, Paychex Flex, and Paylocity do not publish list pricing. Rippling's pricing page is a quote form, so its figure is the payroll starting price on Rippling's small-business page, $8 per user per month plus a $40 monthly base fee. Multi-State Included means the provider's own pages say a second state carries no separate charge or tier upgrade; an X means a charge or upgrade applies, or the provider does not say. VT Tax Filing covers state income tax withholding and unemployment insurance contributions. Support for the Child Care Contribution lines and the Health Care Fund Contribution Assessment lines on Form WHT-436 varies by vendor and plan tier and is not implied by that column; confirm both in writing before signing.

OnPay

OnPay has one payroll plan at $49 per month plus $6 per employee, with HR tools and time tracking sold as optional add-ons rather than tiers.

Tax filing covers all 50 states with no multi-state surcharge, and year-end W-2 and 1099 filing sits in the base price rather than being billed separately. For a Vermont employer with a few people over the New Hampshire line, that flat structure removes the single biggest pricing variable in the state.

Pros
One payroll plan, with HR and time tracking as optional add-ons rather than tiers
Multi-state tax filing included at no surcharge, which matters on a three-border state
Unlimited pay runs, so weekly Vermont schedules carry no per-run penalty
Year-end W-2 and 1099 forms included in the base price
First month free
Cons
HR tools such as custom onboarding workflows cost $15 a month plus $2 per worker
Benefits run through OnPay’s in-house licensed agents unless you connect your own broker of record
Time tracking is a paid add-on at $15 a month plus $4 per worker
Interface is functional rather than polished

Gusto

Gusto is a common first payroll purchase for US small businesses. Tax filing is automatic, the interface is pleasant, and pricing is published. Simple runs $49 per month plus $6 per employee, after a base increase from $40 during 2025.

The catch for Vermont is geography. Simple covers single-state payroll only, and a Vermont company is unusually likely to hire in New Hampshire, New York, or Massachusetts. One such hire moves you to Plus at $80 plus $12 per employee, which nearly doubles a 25-person bill. Model the Plus number if a cross-border hire is even plausible within the next year.

Pros
Built-in onboarding and HR tools alongside payroll
Published pricing with month-to-month billing and no long-term contract
Automated tax filing across federal and state jurisdictions
Large integration library and strong accountant ecosystem
Cons
Simple plan is single-state only: a New Hampshire hire forces the Plus tier
Base price rose from $40 to $49 during 2025
Time tracking sits behind Plus or a paid add-on
Per-employee fees compound: $349 per month at 50 employees on Simple

Patriot Software

Patriot is the lowest-cost full-service option here at every headcount the cost table models. Full Service is $37 per month plus $5 per employee and includes federal, state, and local tax filing, though you still file new hire reports with the state yourself.

Basic is $17 a month plus $4 per employee if you file taxes yourself, which for a Vermont employer means hand-filing WHT-436 with three separate tax sections every quarter. Additional state filings cost $12 per month each, so a Vermont company with two people in New Hampshire pays $12 more rather than jumping a tier. Unlimited pay runs make the weekly Vermont default affordable.

Pros
Lowest total monthly cost here at 10, 25, and 50 employees
Unlimited payroll runs with no per-run fees, which suits weekly Vermont schedules
Second state costs $12 per month rather than forcing a tier upgrade
Free 30-day trial plus 50 percent off the first three months
Cons
$12 per month for each additional state adds up across three borders
Basic plan leaves you filing Vermont deposits and returns yourself
Time tracking and HR are separate paid add-ons
Plain interface, and mobile clock-in in the My Patriot app needs the paid Time & Attendance add-on

SurePayroll

SurePayroll is owned by Paychex and aimed at very small employers and household employers. The Small Business plan is $29 per month plus $7 per employee, with a flat $9.99 monthly multi-state fee regardless of how many states are involved. For a company straddling the New Hampshire border, flat beats per-state.

Pros
Flat $9.99 monthly multi-state fee rather than per-state pricing
Payroll can be scheduled to run automatically
Strong fit for household employers paying nannies or caregivers
Unlimited payroll runs on all plans
Cons
Per-employee fee of $7 is higher than Patriot’s, OnPay’s, or Gusto Simple’s
Time clock integration and accounting sync are paid add-ons
No digital onboarding workflows for collecting W-4VT or HC-2 forms
Interface reads dated compared to newer platforms

QuickBooks Workforce Payroll

QuickBooks Workforce (formerly QuickBooks Payroll) took its new name in May 2026, and the entry tier once called Core is now Workforce Payroll at $50 per month plus $7 per employee. Per-employee pricing rose across all tiers on July 1, 2026, and each additional state adds $12 a month below the Elite tier.

The reason to pick it has always been the same: if your books already live in QuickBooks Online, payroll entries reach the general ledger without an export step.

Pros
Native general ledger sync with QuickBooks Online
Federal and state tax filing on every tier, including the entry tier
Published pricing with no sales call
Same-day direct deposit on higher tiers, useful for the 72-hour discharge rule
Cons
Per-employee pricing increased on July 1, 2026
Workforce Payroll, the entry tier, lacks time tracking and HR support
Weak value if you do not use QuickBooks accounting
Promotional pricing masks the real cost until month four

ADP RUN

ADP pays roughly one in six American workers, according to its fiscal 2026 annual report, and it says every RUN package calculates, files, deposits, and reconciles payroll taxes, with ADP paying the resulting fines if it makes a tax filing error.

For a Vermont employer the practical argument is maintenance. The January wage base change and the July contribution rate change both land with ADP, which includes State Unemployment Insurance management from its Enhanced package up. Confirm in writing how the annual health care assessment rate reset reaches your account.

The cost is opacity. ADP does not publish RUN pricing: the Essential, Enhanced, Complete, and HR Pro packages are all quoted individually. ADP also says no contract is required and you can end service at any time.

Pros
Calculates, files, deposits, and reconciles payroll taxes in every package
Statutory changes reach the tax tables without customer intervention
Multi-state payroll and tax filing included in every package
Deep benefits administration and HR add-on catalog
Cons
No published pricing: every quote requires a sales conversation
Electronic I-9 and garnishment payment services start at the Enhanced package
Add-on modules raise the cost above the base package quote
W-2 and 1099 forms carry an additional fee

Paychex Flex

Paychex competes with ADP on service rather than software, with a payroll specialist included on its top Complete package. Every payroll package (Basic, Foundations, Advanced, and Complete) is priced on request, so like ADP it gives you no published floor to budget against. Worth a call if you would rather ask a person how the HC-2 collection works than read the assessment worksheet.

Pros
Unlimited payroll runs, Taxpay, and W-2 and 1099 processing in every package
Dedicated service representatives available at higher tiers
Full tax filing and compliance support across all jurisdictions
Broad HR, benefits, and retirement services under one vendor
Cons
Quote-only pricing with no published rates at any tier
Time and attendance is an add-on on every package
Dedicated support requires a higher-priced tier
Phone and email support is an add-on on the Basic package

Paylocity

Paylocity sits between small-business payroll and full HCM (human capital management), aimed at companies that have outgrown basic payroll but do not want enterprise complexity. It maintains detailed per-state tax compliance resources, and the HR module covers performance, learning, and engagement alongside payroll. Pricing is quote-based, and implementation is a project rather than a signup.

Pros
Deeper HR functionality than payroll-first providers
Maintains detailed per-state tax compliance resources
Strong employee self-service and mobile experience
Scales into mid-market without replatforming
Cons
Quote-only pricing with no published rates
Consultant-led implementation rather than self-serve setup
More platform than a small Vermont business needs
Implementation fees are charged on top of the subscription

Rippling

Rippling sells a unified employee record where payroll, HR, and IT provisioning share one data model. Its pricing page lists no rates, but Rippling's small-business page starts payroll plans at $8 per user per month plus a $40 monthly base fee, and its blog prices the core platform and the payroll module at $8 per employee a month each (payroll is $10 billed monthly), so a configured quote runs higher.

Rippling's blog also estimates roughly $15 to $25 per employee per month for a 100-employee company running the human resources information system (HRIS), payroll, benefits administration, and time and attendance modules, so a working configuration costs well above the headline core rate.

Pros
Single employee record spanning HR, payroll, and IT provisioning
A single hire event can trigger account setup, app access, and a laptop order, by Rippling’s own account
Handles multi-state tax registration within the same workflow
Scales from startup to mid-market without replatforming
Cons
Modular pricing means the headline $8 figure is not what anyone pays
The pricing page itself lists no rates, so every contract is a custom quote
Each product is bought separately alongside the required core platform
Overbuilt for a small Vermont business with no IT complexity

Justworks

Justworks sells two products under one name. Payroll is $50 per month plus $8 per employee and is straightforward software. The other is a professional employer organization (PEO): PEO Basic, at $79 per employee per month, is a co-employment arrangement covering compliance, HR tools, 24/7 support, and a 401(k), but not medical coverage.

Justworks PEO Plus, at $124 per employee per month, adds medical, dental, and vision administration, giving a small Vermont business access to benefits priced off a much larger risk pool. In a state where the health care assessment is driven by how many employees are uncovered, that pooling argument has a second edge, because covering more employees can also shrink the assessment.

Pros
PEO pooling gives small teams access to larger-group benefits pricing
Published per-employee pricing, unusual among PEOs
Multi-state payroll and filings included on the Payroll tier
24/7 support on both PEO plans
Cons
PEO pricing at $79 per employee is far above standalone payroll software
Health premiums and workers compensation are separate pass-through costs
Co-employment is a structural change, not a software swap
Pooled pricing can work against teams with healthier-than-average claims
Departments
Dwight SchruteSales3 people
Darryl PhilbinWarehouse1 person
Kelly KapoorCustomer Service1 person
Core HR
Who works here and who does what
Profiles, departments and an org chart, with every change kept on record.

What each provider actually costs a Vermont employer

The table below models published rates at three headcounts, plus what happens when a second state enters the picture. That second-state column carries more weight in Vermont than in almost any other state, because the population centers sit within commuting distance of two or three borders.

Provider10 employees25 employees50 employees2nd State FeeNotes
Patriot$87$162$287$12/moPer extra state
SurePayroll$99$204$379$9.99/moFlat, all states
OnPay$109$199$349$0None
Gusto Simple$109$199$349UpgradePlus tier required
QuickBooks$120$225$400$12/moPer extra state below Elite
Justworks$130$250$450IncludedNone
Paychex FlexQuoteQuoteQuoteQuoteNo published package prices
Monthly base plus per-employee fees at standard published rates, verified October 2026. Excludes promotional discounts, benefits premiums, workers compensation, and year-end form fees where charged separately. Paychex Flex quotes all four of its payroll packages individually, so its row shows quote only. These figures exclude the Child Care Contribution and the Health Care Fund Contribution Assessment themselves, which are employer taxes rather than software fees.

Two patterns stand out. Patriot stays cheapest at every headcount, and at 50 employees it runs $62 a month below OnPay and Gusto Simple and $92 below SurePayroll. But the second-state column reorders things: Gusto Simple matches OnPay exactly until one cross-border hire forces the Plus tier, at which point a 25-person payroll goes from $199 to $380 per month while OnPay stays at $199.

Software price is also not the whole Vermont number. An employer with 25 full-time people, no group health plan, and nobody insured elsewhere reaches 25 uncovered full-time equivalents, and after the four-equivalent exemption owes the health care assessment on 21 of them every quarter. Multiply 21 by the current per-equivalent rate before you decide the subscription is the big line.

The Child Care Contribution adds 0.44 percent of Vermont wages on top, or 0.33 percent if you take the maximum employee deduction. Both are statutory costs no provider changes, and they belong in the budget next to the subscription line rather than in a separate mental category.

Tip
Model your 18-month headcount and your 18-month map
Take your current Vermont headcount and your projected headcount 18 months out, then ask three questions: will anyone be working outside Vermont, how many employees will be uncovered by a group health plan, and will you still be running weekly. Price each provider against both headcounts and all three answers. The provider that looks cheapest for a single-state weekly payroll of eight people is frequently not the one that stays cheapest once a New Hampshire hire and a benefits plan appear.

Choosing a payroll provider for Vermont

Four questions separate providers that will work here from providers that will quietly generate correction notices.

Questions for a Vermont payroll provider
Does it populate the Child Care Contribution lines on Form WHT-436?The contribution rides on the same quarterly return as income tax withholding but has a different base and an employer-elected employee deduction of up to 0.11 percent. Ask specifically whether the platform calculates the 0.44 percent, applies your per-employee withholding election, reports the withheld portion in Box 14 of the W-2, and populates the WHT-436 lines, or whether it expects you to compute and key those figures yourself. A system that files Vermont withholding correctly can still leave this entirely manual.
Can it track uncovered employees and the HC-2 declarations?The health care assessment is driven by hours worked by uncovered employees, capped at 520 per individual per quarter, less the first four full-time equivalents. It depends on having a current HC-2 on file for every employee not on your plan, refreshed annually, because a missing declaration means that person counts as uncovered. Ask whether the platform tracks coverage status per employee, whether it can produce the hours figure the HC-1 worksheet needs, and whether it will prompt you when a declaration is more than a year old.
What does an off-cycle payroll run cost, and how fast can it land?A discharged Vermont employee must be paid within 72 hours, which frequently falls outside a normal cycle. Confirm two things: whether off-cycle runs are unlimited or billed per run, and how many business days the provider needs to originate a direct deposit or produce a physical check. A two-day funding window plus a weekend can breach the deadline even when the provider technically supports off-cycle payments. Weekly pay is also the statutory default here, so unlimited runs are worth more in Vermont than in most states.
How does the platform price a second state?Vermont borders three states and small employers cross those lines routinely. The pricing models differ sharply: some providers include every state at no surcharge, some charge a flat monthly multi-state fee, some charge per additional state, and at least one forces a tier upgrade that can nearly double the bill. Ask what happens on the day you hire one person in New Hampshire, and get the answer in writing. This single variable reorders the cost ranking more than any other.

One item sits outside the payroll engine entirely: the new-hire paperwork. Every Vermont new hire needs a federal I-9 and W-4, plus a W-4VT, which you have to ask each employee for rather than wait to receive.

A new hire who is not joining your health plan also needs an HC-2, and anyone paid electronically needs a signed direct deposit authorization before you can pay them that way at all.

Before you choose

FirstHR is an onboarding and HR platform, not a payroll provider. The providers above calculate Vermont withholding, move money, administer benefits, and file payroll taxes, from the quarterly WHT-436 to the annual WHT-434 reconciliation.

Every provider above does something we do not, and if running payroll is the problem in front of you, one of them is the answer rather than us.

What we handle is the layer that feeds payroll: onboarding workflows that put the I-9, the W-4, and Form W-4VT on each new hire's first-day task list, e-signatures on offer letters, employee records, and HR document management for small US teams at a flat $98 a month for up to 10 people or $198 for 11 to 50.

If the recurring problem in your Vermont payroll is that the W-4VT never got requested, three people never returned an HC-2 and you paid the assessment for them anyway, and nobody is sure whether the direct deposit form was ever signed, that is a document collection failure rather than a payroll processing failure, and it is the kind of gap we built for.

Each of those forms can sit on the onboarding plan as a task with a deadline. The forms themselves are completed outside the platform, and the signed copies are kept in the employee file.

Invite your team to FirstHR
4.7 on G2
Ryan HowardActive
Jim HalpertOn Leave
Key takeaways
1Vermont withholds income tax on a graduated schedule with four marginal rates from 3.35 to 8.75 percent, driven by Form W-4VT, with no local income tax anywhere in the state. Extra withholding requested on a federal W-4 converts to Vermont at 30 percent of the federal amount, not one for one.
2Unemployment contributions are employer-paid on the first $15,400 of wages for 2026, up from $14,800. Most new employers pay 1 percent. Experience rates come from 21 rate classes inside one of five statutory schedules, running as low as 0.4 percent and as high as 8.4 percent depending on which schedule is in effect.
3The Child Care Contribution adds 0.44 percent of Vermont wages, reported on the same quarterly form as withholding. The employer may deduct up to one quarter of it, meaning 0.11 percent, from each employee, and the election is per employee.
4The Health Care Fund Contribution Assessment is charged per uncovered full-time equivalent per quarter after the first four are exempted. A missing HC-2 declaration means the employee counts as uncovered, and the assessment cannot be deducted from employee pay.
5Wages are due weekly unless employees have been given notice of a biweekly or semimonthly schedule. A discharged employee is paid within 72 hours; an employee who quits is paid on the last regular pay day, or the following Friday if there is none.
6On published rates, Patriot costs least at 10, 25, and 50 employees, while OnPay and Justworks add nothing for a second state and Patriot and QuickBooks charge $12 a month for each extra state.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the Vermont income tax rate for payroll withholding?

Vermont uses a graduated schedule with four marginal rates: 3.35, 6.60, 7.60, and 8.75 percent. Withholding is calculated by subtracting the employee's allowances from wages and applying the table for that filing status and pay period from GB-1210, which the Department of Taxes reissues each January. No Vermont municipality levies an income tax.

Do Vermont employees have to complete Form W-4VT?

The Department of Taxes strongly recommends that employers require it. Without a W-4VT the employer may use the federal W-4, but the Department warns this can under-withhold, particularly for employees who adjusted their federal withholding for a federal credit and for employees in a civil union or civil marriage.

How does extra withholding on a federal W-4 affect Vermont tax?

It converts at 30 percent. If an employee requests extra federal withholding on the federal W-4 each pay period, Vermont withholding rises by 30 percent of that extra amount rather than by the full figure. Putting the intended Vermont amount on a W-4VT avoids the conversion entirely.

What is the Vermont unemployment insurance wage base?

$15,400 per employee for calendar year 2026, up $600 from $14,800. Contributions are employer-paid with nothing withheld from employees. The cap limits the annual cost per head to $154 at the 1 percent new employer rate and about $1,294 at the highest statutory rate, and someone earning about $61,600 a year hits it within the first quarter.

What unemployment rate does a new Vermont employer pay?

One percent for most new employers. Out-of-state corporations in NAICS 236, 237, and 238, the construction groupings, are assigned an industry-average rate instead. Because experience rating needs a full calendar year of benefit liability at minimum and rates are reset only once a year, most employers pay the new employer rate for two years or longer.

How are experience-rated unemployment rates calculated?

From a benefit ratio: the benefits charged to your account over the past one to three calendar years, divided by your taxable wages for those years. The Department of Labor uses that ratio to place you in one of 21 rate classes. Section 1326 provides five rate schedules, each with 21 rates, running from a low of 0.4 percent to a high of 8.4 percent.

What is the Vermont Child Care Contribution?

A 0.44 percent payroll tax on Vermont wages, created by Act 76 of 2023 and effective for wages paid on or after July 1, 2024. The employer owes the full amount and may elect to deduct up to one quarter of it, meaning 0.11 percent, from employee wages, leaving 0.33 percent as the employer share.

How is the Child Care Contribution reported?

On Form WHT-436, the quarterly withholding reconciliation, using dedicated lines. Payments are remitted at the same frequency as Vermont income tax withholding. Any portion deducted from an employee is reported in Box 14 of that employee's W-2, and only wages subject to Vermont withholding are subject to the contribution.

What is the Health Care Fund Contribution Assessment?

A quarterly employer assessment per uncovered full-time equivalent employee. Divide total hours worked by uncovered employees by 520, capping any individual at 520 hours, round down, subtract four for the exemption, and multiply by the current rate. The rate resets annually to track the second-lowest-cost silver plan on the Vermont Health Benefit Exchange.

Why does Form HC-2 matter for Vermont employers?

Because an employee with no HC-2 on file must be treated as uncovered, and the Department is required to assess for them on audit. Declarations are collected annually and again whenever coverage changes. Employers keep HC-2 and HC-1 for three years without filing them, and an employer with four or fewer uncovered full-time equivalents still files a zero return.

How often must Vermont employers pay employees?

Weekly by default under 21 V.S.A. section 342, for wages earned to a day not more than six days before payment. Biweekly or semimonthly is allowed after giving notice to each employee, and a collective bargaining agreement can push the lag to 13 days. Direct deposit and pay cards require written authorization.

What is the final paycheck deadline in Vermont?

A discharged employee must be paid within 72 hours of discharge. An employee who quits is paid on the last regular pay day, or the following Friday if there is no regular pay day. An employee absent from the workplace on payday is entitled to payment upon demand.

What is the Vermont minimum wage and is it indexed?

$14.42 an hour since January 1, 2026, up from $14.01, and the basic tipped wage is $7.21. Yes, it is indexed: each January, 21 V.S.A. section 384 raises the rate by five percent or by the 12-month change in the Consumer Price Index for all urban consumers to the previous September 1, whichever is smaller, and the rate can never decrease.

How much does payroll software cost for a Vermont small business?

At 10 employees, published October 2026 rates run roughly $87 for Patriot Full Service, $99 for SurePayroll, $109 for OnPay or Gusto Simple, $120 for QuickBooks Workforce Payroll, and $130 for Justworks Payroll. At 50 employees the same plans land between $287 and $450, while ADP RUN, Paychex Flex, and Paylocity quote every account.

Make HR the easy part of running your business

Onboarding, e-signatures, training and core HR in one place. Up and running in 5 minutes.

  • 7-day free trial
  • No credit card required
  • Cancel anytime
4.7 on G2300+ companies trust FirstHR