FirstHR

Performance Appraisal Form: 6 Printable Forms

Free performance appraisal form templates for small business: simple, annual, self-appraisal, 90-day, manager, and 360. EEO-aware. Download as DOCX.

TL;DR
A performance appraisal form evaluates job performance with a defined rating scale and job-related competencies, plus goals, comments, and signatures. Appraisal is chiefly British for what US teams call a performance review; the document is the same. Keep criteria job-related and apply them consistently to stay EEO-aware. Download six forms as DOCX, from a simple one-pager to a light 360.
Category
Updated
Oct
15
2026
Reading time
15min

If another founder asked me where to begin with performance reviews, I would point them to a good form first, and this page gives you six. A performance appraisal form is the document a manager uses to evaluate an employee's work over a review period: a rating scale, a set of job-related competencies, a look at goals, room for comments, and signatures.

For a small business running its first formal reviews, the form is what keeps the conversation focused on actual work instead of vague impressions, and it creates the written record you will want later. Performance appraisal is the term more common in British English; if your team says performance review or employee evaluation, it means the same thing.

These six forms cover the reviews a small business runs: a simple one-pager, a comprehensive annual form, an employee self-appraisal, a 90-day form for new hires, a manager and leadership form, and a light 360. Each is free to download, written with equal employment opportunity (EEO) rules in mind, and built around job-related criteria a small team can use without an HR department.

My TeamPam BeeslyFull-timeJim HalpertFull-timeRyan HowardPart-time
Core HR
Your team's records in one place
A profile and documents for each person, and the org chart built from them.
Start free trial7-day free trial, no credit card

What a Performance Appraisal Form Is

A performance appraisal form is a structured document for evaluating an employee's job performance over a set period, usually a year. It pairs a defined rating scale with job-related competencies such as quality of work, productivity, job knowledge, communication, and teamwork, and adds a review of goals, space for comments, a development plan, and signature lines.

The term itself is mostly a question of dialect. Performance appraisal is the usual phrasing in British English, while US businesses more often say performance review or employee evaluation. The Oxford Advanced Learner's Dictionary lists the two as synonyms and labels appraisal especially British.

Whichever name your team uses, the purpose of the review is the same: give the employee clear, fair feedback on their work, recognize what went well, and set goals for what comes next. A good form makes that process consistent from one employee and one manager to the next.

What to Include in a Performance Appraisal Form

A complete appraisal form has four building blocks: context, ratings, goals and development, and sign-off. A strong form covers all four without becoming a sprawling enterprise document. The sections below show what belongs in each.

Header and context
Employee, reviewer, and review period
Job title and department
Review date and type
Ratings and competencies
A clear, defined rating scale (often 5-point)
Job-related competency categories
An overall rating
Goals and development
Review of prior-period goals
Strengths and areas to improve
Next-period goals and training
Comments and sign-off
Manager comments and self-assessment
Dual signature lines
Acknowledgment, not agreement, clause

The simple one-pager keeps each block short; the annual form expands them with a full competency matrix and goal-by-goal review.

Which Form Should You Use?

Pick the form by the kind of review you are running. The core structure is the same across all six, but each one emphasizes the sections and language that fit a specific review. Use this guide to choose the closest fit, then adjust.

Simple One-Page Form· First formal review
One page in plain language: core competencies rated on a 5-point scale, strengths and areas to improve, and up to three goals for the next period. Start here if this is your first round of formal reviews.
Preview
Annual (Comprehensive)· Year-end review
The most complete of the six: every competency rated with comments, last year's goals checked one by one, the employee's self-assessment, a development plan, and goals for the year ahead.
Preview
Employee Self-Appraisal· Employee completes it
The employee fills it in before the meeting, covering accomplishments, missed goals, and training needs, then rates themselves on the scale the manager uses.
Preview
Probationary / 90-Day· New hire, end of intro period
Closes out a new hire's introductory period with a clear decision to continue, extend, or separate, worded with at-will employment in mind.
Preview
Manager / Leadership· Reviewing a manager
Rates how someone with direct reports leads (delegation, coaching, and decisions) alongside what the team delivered and the manager's own development goals.
Preview
360-Degree (Light)· Multi-rater input
Gathers input on behaviors from the employee, peers, the manager, and direct reports without enterprise tooling, and treats the results as development input rather than a score.
Preview
Tip
Match the Form to the Review
First formal review at a small business: Simple One-Page. Year-end review: Annual. Employee preparing before the meeting: Self-Appraisal. New hire at the end of an introductory period: Probationary / 90-Day. Reviewing someone who manages a team: Manager / Leadership. Multi-rater feedback without enterprise tooling: 360-Degree (Light). When in doubt, start with the Simple One-Page form and expand from there.

6 Free Performance Appraisal Form Templates

Download all six as Word files in a single zip, or copy and download individual forms. Each follows the same structure: header and review details, a defined rating scale, job-related competencies, goals and comments, and signature lines with an acknowledgment clause. Fill in the blanks and use it.

Download All 6 Appraisal Forms
Simple, annual, self-appraisal, 90-day, manager, and 360. Six DOCX files in a single zip.

Template 1: Simple Performance Appraisal Form (One Page)

The plain-language version for a small business running its first reviews: a 5-point scale across core competencies, strengths, areas to improve, and three goals, all on one page.

Simple Performance Appraisal Form (One Page)
SIMPLE PERFORMANCE APPRAISAL FORM
Company:

EMPLOYEE AND REVIEW DETAILS

Employee name:
Job title:
Manager / reviewer:
Review period: to
Review date:

RATING SCALE

Rate each area from 1 to 5:
1 = Below expectations 2 = Needs improvement 3 = Meets expectations
4 = Exceeds expectations 5 = Outstanding

CORE COMPETENCIES

Quality of work ............................ [ 1 ] [ 2 ] [ 3 ] [ 4 ] [ 5 ]
Productivity and reliability ............... [ 1 ] [ 2 ] [ 3 ] [ 4 ] [ 5 ]
Job knowledge and skill .................... [ 1 ] [ 2 ] [ 3 ] [ 4 ] [ 5 ]
Communication .............................. [ 1 ] [ 2 ] [ 3 ] [ 4 ] [ 5 ]
Teamwork and attitude ...................... [ 1 ] [ 2 ] [ 3 ] [ 4 ] [ 5 ]
Initiative and problem solving ............. [ 1 ] [ 2 ] [ 3 ] [ 4 ] [ 5 ]
Overall rating ............................. [ 1 ] [ 2 ] [ 3 ] [ 4 ] [ 5 ]

SUMMARY

Key strengths:
Areas to improve:
Goals for the next period (up to three):
1.
2.
3.
Manager comments:

SIGNATURES

Employee signature: Date:
Manager signature: Date:
The employee signature confirms the review was discussed, not necessarily
agreement with its contents.

Template 2: Annual Performance Appraisal Form (Comprehensive)

The full version for a year-end review: a competency matrix, goal-by-goal accounting against last year, self-assessment, development plan, and next-year objectives.

Annual Performance Appraisal Form (Comprehensive)
ANNUAL PERFORMANCE APPRAISAL FORM
Company:
Review period: to

EMPLOYEE INFORMATION

Employee name:
Job title:
Department:
Manager / reviewer:
Date of review:

RATING SCALE

5 = Outstanding 4 = Exceeds expectations 3 = Meets expectations
2 = Needs improvement 1 = Below expectations

COMPETENCY RATINGS

Job knowledge ......................... Rating: Comments:
Quality of work ....................... Rating: Comments:
Productivity .......................... Rating: Comments:
Communication ......................... Rating: Comments:
Teamwork and collaboration ............ Rating: Comments:
Dependability and attendance .......... Rating: Comments:
Initiative and judgment ............... Rating: Comments:

GOAL REVIEW (FROM LAST PERIOD)

Goal 1: Result: [ ] Achieved [ ] Partial [ ] Missed
Goal 2: Result: [ ] Achieved [ ] Partial [ ] Missed
Goal 3: Result: [ ] Achieved [ ] Partial [ ] Missed
Notes on goal performance:

EMPLOYEE SELF-ASSESSMENT

Biggest accomplishments this period:
Challenges or obstacles:

DEVELOPMENT PLAN AND NEXT-PERIOD GOALS

Development areas and training:
Goals for next period:
1.
2.
3.

OVERALL RATING AND SIGNATURES

Overall rating: Manager summary:
Employee signature: Date:
Manager signature: Date:
Reviewer / next-level signature: Date:
The employee signature confirms the review was discussed, not necessarily
agreement with its contents.
Everyone in one list, with who they report to
Position, department, type, manager and status for each person. People who have left move to a separate list.

Template 3: Employee Self-Appraisal Form

For the employee to complete before the meeting: accomplishments, unmet goals and why, training needs, and a self-rating on the same scale the manager uses.

Employee Self-Appraisal Form
EMPLOYEE SELF-APPRAISAL FORM
Company:
Review period: to

YOUR INFORMATION

Name:
Job title:
Manager:
Date completed:

SELF-ASSESSMENT

Complete this before your review meeting. Be honest and specific. Your manager
will use it alongside their own assessment.
What were your main accomplishments this period?
Which responsibilities or goals went well, and why?
Which goals were not met, and what got in the way?
What would you like to do or learn in the next period?
What support, tools, or training would help you do your job better?

SELF-RATING

Rate yourself from 1 (below expectations) to 5 (outstanding):
Quality of work ............................ Rating: ____
Productivity and reliability ............... Rating: ____
Job knowledge and skill .................... Rating: ____
Communication .............................. Rating: ____
Teamwork and attitude ...................... Rating: ____
Initiative and problem solving ............. Rating: ____
Overall self-rating ........................ Rating: ____

SIGNATURE

Employee signature: Date:

Template 4: Probationary / 90-Day Appraisal Form

For evaluating a new hire at the end of an introductory period, with role-specific expectations and a clear continue, extend, or separate decision in at-will-aware language. That wording matters: according to the Society for Human Resource Management (SHRM, 2019), some courts have ruled that completing a probationary period suggests express or implied contract obligations, which makes an at-will discharge harder.

Probationary / 90-Day Appraisal Form
PROBATIONARY / 90-DAY APPRAISAL FORM
Company:

NEW HIRE INFORMATION

Employee name:
Job title:
Start date: Review date:
Manager / reviewer:
Introductory period: to

RATING SCALE

3 = Meets or exceeds expectations 2 = Developing, on track
1 = Below expectations for this stage

ROLE-SPECIFIC EXPECTATIONS

Learned core job duties .................... Rating: ____
Quality and accuracy of work ............... Rating: ____
Productivity and pace ...................... Rating: ____
Follows policies and procedures ............ Rating: ____
Communication and teamwork ................. Rating: ____
Reliability and attendance ................. Rating: ____

GOALS FROM ONBOARDING

Were the 30, 60, and 90-day goals met?
[ ] Yes, all [ ] Most [ ] Some [ ] Few
Notes:

MANAGER ASSESSMENT

Strengths in the first 90 days:
Areas to develop:

EMPLOYMENT DECISION

[ ] Continue employment, introductory period successfully completed
[ ] Extend introductory period to (state reason below)
[ ] End employment
Notes on decision:
Reminder: some courts have read completing a probationary period as implying
contract obligations, and Montana requires good cause for a discharge after it.
Keep this wording neutral and state at-will status in writing where it applies.
This is general information, not legal advice.

SIGNATURES

Employee signature: Date:
Manager signature: Date:
The employee signature confirms the review was discussed, not necessarily
agreement with its contents.

Template 5: Manager / Leadership Appraisal Form

For someone with direct reports: leadership competencies like delegation, coaching, and decision-making, plus team outcomes and development goals.

Manager / Leadership Appraisal Form
MANAGER / LEADERSHIP APPRAISAL FORM
Company:
Review period: to

MANAGER INFORMATION

Name:
Title:
Reviewer:
Team size:
Date of review:

RATING SCALE

5 = Outstanding 4 = Exceeds expectations 3 = Meets expectations
2 = Needs improvement 1 = Below expectations

LEADERSHIP COMPETENCIES

Delegation and prioritization .............. Rating: ____
Coaching and developing the team ........... Rating: ____
Decision-making and judgment ............... Rating: ____
Communication and transparency ............. Rating: ____
Accountability and follow-through .......... Rating: ____
Hiring, onboarding, and retention .......... Rating: ____
Conflict resolution ........................ Rating: ____

TEAM OUTCOMES

Key results the team delivered this period:
Team health (engagement, turnover, morale):

DEVELOPMENT

Leadership strengths:
Development goals for next period:
1.
2.
Reviewer comments:
Overall rating: ____

SIGNATURES

Manager signature: Date:
Reviewer signature: Date:
The signature confirms the review was discussed, not necessarily agreement
with its contents.

Template 6: 360-Degree Feedback Appraisal Form (Light)

For multi-rater feedback without enterprise tooling: self, peer, manager, and direct-report input on behaviors, used developmentally rather than as a single score.

360-Degree Feedback Appraisal Form (Light)
360-DEGREE FEEDBACK APPRAISAL FORM (LIGHT)
Company:
Employee being reviewed:
Review period: to

ABOUT THIS FORM

This is a developmental tool, not a scored evaluation. Collect this form from a
few raters (the employee, a manager, and one or two peers or direct reports) to
build a rounded picture. Keep responses constructive.
Your relationship to this employee:
[ ] Self [ ] Manager [ ] Peer [ ] Direct report

RATING SCALE

5 = Always 4 = Often 3 = Sometimes 2 = Rarely 1 = Never
NA = Unable to assess

BEHAVIOR-BASED QUESTIONS

Communicates clearly and listens well ...... Rating: ____
Collaborates and supports the team .......... Rating: ____
Delivers quality work on time ............... Rating: ____
Takes ownership and follows through ......... Rating: ____
Handles feedback and conflict well .......... Rating: ____
Demonstrates job knowledge and skill ........ Rating: ____

OPEN FEEDBACK

What does this person do well that they should keep doing?
What is one thing this person could do to grow or improve?
Any other constructive comments:

NOTE

Aggregate responses across raters before sharing with the employee. Use the
themes for development, not as a single overall score. Keeping individual
responses confidential encourages honest, useful feedback.

Keeping Appraisals Fair and EEO-Aware

The habits that make an appraisal fair also make it defensible: job-related criteria, consistent standards, and specific documentation. That matters because a completed appraisal can become evidence if a pay, promotion, or employment decision is ever questioned. Here is what to keep in mind.

Core rule
Rate job performance, not the person
The single most important rule for an appraisal form is that it measures actual job performance, not personality or protected characteristics. The U.S. Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC) is explicit that performance appraisals should be based on employees' actual job performance. In practice that means rating competencies tied to the role (quality, productivity, job knowledge, communication) rather than vague traits, and backing ratings with specific facts. A form built around defined, job-related competencies and a clear scale is far easier to apply fairly than a blank comment box. The templates here are structured this way on purpose. This is general information, not legal advice.
Consistency
Apply the same standards consistently
Two employees doing comparable work should be measured against the same standards and receive comparable ratings regardless of who evaluates them. The EEOC advises employers to communicate performance standards when someone is hired and to apply those standards consistently at review time, so that appraisals are neither artificially low nor artificially high. For a small business, that means using the same form and the same rating scale for everyone in similar roles, and making sure managers understand how to use it. Consistency is your best protection if a rating is ever questioned, and it makes reviews more useful to employees. This is general information, not legal advice.
Evidence
Document with specific, factual examples
A rating is only as defensible as the evidence behind it. The EEOC notes that including relevant facts can help employees understand the basis for a rating and help managers apply standards consistently, for example noting that an employee exceeded a production standard by a measurable amount over a set number of weeks. Avoid vague language like “good attitude” or “needs to do better.” Tie each rating to what actually happened: results delivered, deadlines met or missed, specific behaviors. The comment fields on these forms exist for exactly that, and a completed, documented appraisal is a far stronger record than a remembered conversation. This is general information, not legal advice.
Signature
Mind the signature and at-will language
The signature line on an appraisal should make clear that signing confirms the review was discussed, not that the employee agrees with it. These templates include that acknowledgment clause, which institutional appraisal forms use too. For a probationary or 90-day appraisal, be careful that completing an introductory period does not unintentionally imply a change to at-will status or create a contract; keep the language neutral and state at-will status in writing where it applies. When an appraisal supports a significant decision like ending employment, consistent documentation matters most. This is general information, not legal advice.
Good to know
Base Appraisals on Actual Job Performance
The EEOC advises employers to make sure performance appraisals are based on employees' actual job performance, with comparable performance receiving comparable ratings regardless of the evaluator. When conducting evaluations, communicate standards up front, apply them consistently, and back ratings with specific facts.

None of this requires an HR department. A structured form with defined, job-related competencies does most of the work, because it keeps managers rating the same things the same way.

Choosing a Rating Scale

The rating scale is the heart of the form. According to SHRM (2014), 3-point and 5-point scales are the most prevalent in appraisal systems; the 5-point version gives enough range without overwhelming the rater. Define each level in plain words so every manager reads them the same way.

ScaleBest forTrade-off
5-point (1 to 5)Annual reviews, most rolesThe default; needs clear level definitions
3-pointProbationary, simple reviewsFast, but less nuance between levels
4-pointAvoiding a neutral middleForces a lean; can feel harsh
Behavior-anchored360 and skills-based reviewsMost defensible, but more to write

Whichever you pick, use the same scale for everyone in similar roles, and anchor each rating to a specific example. A clearly defined scale is both fairer to the employee and easier to stand behind. The simple and annual forms above use a 5-point scale; the 90-day form uses a 3-point scale suited to a new hire.

Sample Wording for Each Rating

A useful sample performance review comment does three things in two or three sentences: it names what the employee actually did, ties that to the rating, and says what happens next. Vague praise and vague criticism are what make a review feel arbitrary, and they are also what makes a rating hard to stand behind later.

CompetencyMeets expectationsNeeds improvement
Quality of workWork comes back clean; caught the invoicing error before it reached the client.Three of the last ten orders needed rework, so we agreed on a self-check before submitting.
ProductivityCarried the heaviest ticket volume on the team for two quarters without missing a deadline.Two projects shipped late this period, both because the work started in the final week.
Job knowledgeSix months in, this is the person the team asks about the new system.Still needs help with pricing exceptions; shadowing continues through the next quarter.
CommunicationRaises problems early and in writing, so nobody finds out at the deadline.Updates tend to arrive after the fact. Expectation going forward: a written status note each Friday.
TeamworkCovered two shifts during a short-staffed month without being asked.Pushback in team meetings has been sharp enough that others stopped raising issues.
DependabilityReady at the start of every scheduled shift this period, with time off requested in advance.Four late starts this quarter, none flagged ahead of time as the policy asks.

The table covers two levels, meets expectations and needs improvement. Most cells give only the evidence, so add the rating and the next step when you write the full comment. For exceeds expectations or outstanding, name the result that set the work apart. For below expectations, name the missed standard, the support you will give, and when you will check again.

Write the comment the way you would say it out loud, then cut anything you could not back up with a specific example. Collect the self-appraisal first: it usually surfaces work you did not see, and it keeps the meeting a conversation rather than a verdict.

Working one competency at a time is far easier than facing a blank form. If attendance is the part you are stuck on, there is a longer set of attendance review phrases to borrow from, and a fuller guide to writing the review itself.

Departments
Dwight SchruteSales3 people
Darryl PhilbinWarehouse1 person
Kelly KapoorCustomer Service1 person
Core HR
Who works here and who does what
Profiles, departments and an org chart, with every change kept on record.

Quarterly, Mid-Year, and Six-Month Reviews

You do not need a separate document for every cadence. A quarterly review template and a mid-year review template are the same appraisal form with a narrower scope: what moved since the last review, whether the goals are still realistic, and one thing to change before the annual.

ReviewWhenForm to useWhat it covers
Quarterly check-inEvery three monthsSimple one-pageProgress on this quarter’s goals, blockers, one change to make
Mid-year reviewHalfway through the annual cycleSimple one-page plus the goal section of the annual formGoal status at the midpoint, course correction, any rating trending down
Six-month reviewSix months after hire90-day form plus next-period goalsWhether the early expectations held, scope changes, first development goals
Annual appraisalOnce a year, same month for everyoneAnnual (comprehensive)Full competency ratings, goal-by-goal review, development plan

Keep the lighter reviews short on purpose. A quarterly review that takes twenty minutes actually happens; one that copies the annual form gets postponed until it turns into the annual review anyway. A sensible rhythm for a small team is one full appraisal a year, a mid-year check, and a 90-day review for every new hire.

If you already hold regular one-on-one meetings, the quarterly version can be one of those: attach the goals and comments sections of the form and skip the ratings. Nothing new lands on the calendar, and the notes still end up on file.

Appraisals for a Small Business

A large company runs appraisals through an HR team, a performance platform, and a calibration committee. A small business runs them with an owner, a spreadsheet, and not much time. Here is how to make appraisals work at your scale, and why a structured form matters more, not less, when you do not have HR.

Most appraisal forms are built for an HR department you do not have
Most appraisal forms you find online come from large template farms or from universities and government agencies, and they assume an HR coordinator, multi-level approval chains, and a formal rating committee. A small business has none of that. The owner or a team lead runs the review between everything else, often for the first time. The forms here are written for that reality: the simple form fits on one page in plain language, and every version skips the enterprise jargon. Pick the one that matches the review you are running, fill in the brackets, and use it, instead of cutting a sprawling corporate form down to size.
A blank box invites bias; a structured form prevents it
When a manager sits down to evaluate someone with nothing but a blank page, the result tends to be vague, inconsistent, and harder to defend, and it is exactly where bias creeps in. A form built around defined, job-related competencies and a clear rating scale forces the conversation onto actual work: quality, productivity, job knowledge, goals met or missed. That is both fairer to the employee and safer for the business, since the EEOC expects appraisals to rest on consistent, job-related criteria. That structure is what keeps a small-business review honest and useful. Use the same form for everyone in similar roles.
The form is step one; running the cycle is the real work
A downloaded form gets you one review. The harder part is running the cycle: collecting self-appraisals, scheduling each review, getting sign-off, and keeping completed appraisals where you can find them next year. For a small business doing this by hand, it slips. FirstHR fits this people side: send the self-appraisal form as a task with a deadline that shows up in the self-service portal, e-sign the completed form, store it on the employee profile so review history lives in one place, and set the next review as a task with its own deadline, so it sits on the task list rather than in someone's memory. The free forms above work on their own; FirstHR is how you run the whole cycle without the paperwork.

From Form to Review Cycle

The form is step one. The real work is running the cycle on a schedule, and at a small business that comes down to the four steps below. None of them is hard on its own; the risk is that one gets skipped in a busy month.

1
Collect the self-appraisal
Send the self-appraisal form ahead of the meeting as a task with a deadline, so it shows up in the self-service portal and the employee comes prepared.
2
Run and document the review
Complete the appraisal form with specific, job-related ratings and comments, then discuss it with the employee.
3
Sign and store it
E-sign the completed form and store it on the employee profile, so review history lives in one place for next time.
4
Schedule the next review
Set the next review date as a task with a deadline, so it sits on the task list instead of slipping through the cracks.

The forms above run a single review on their own. To run the whole cycle, FirstHR ties it together: send self-appraisal forms as tasks that show up in the self-service portal, e-sign completed forms, store review history on the employee profile, and schedule the next review with task workflows. Applicant tracking is coming soon to FirstHR.

Invite your team to FirstHR
4.7 on G2
Ryan HowardActive
Jim HalpertOn Leave
Key takeaways
1A performance appraisal form evaluates job performance with a defined rating scale, job-related competencies, goals, comments, and signatures.
2Appraisal is the term British English favors for what US businesses call a performance review or employee evaluation; the document is the same.
3Use the form that matches the review: simple one-pager, annual, self-appraisal, 90-day, manager, or light 360.
4Keep criteria job-related and apply the same standards consistently; the EEOC expects appraisals to rest on actual job performance.
5A 5-point scale fits most reviews; define each level in plain words and anchor ratings to specific examples.
6The form runs one review; running the cycle (self-appraisals, sign-off, storage, and scheduling) is the part that pays off over time.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is a performance appraisal form?

A performance appraisal form is the written tool a manager or business owner fills in to judge how well an employee did their job during a set review period. Most versions open with details on the employee and the reviewer, then define a rating scale and name the job-related competencies to be rated, for instance work quality, productivity, job knowledge, communication, and teamwork. They also look back at the goals set last time, leave room for comments and a development plan, and close with signature lines. Once it is filled in, the form becomes the written record of that review. In the US, performance review or employee evaluation is the more common name for the same document, since appraisal is largely a British label; the purpose does not change. A good form keeps every rating pointed at real work rather than general impressions, so the review ends up fairer and more useful.

What should a performance appraisal form include?

A complete performance appraisal form starts with a header naming the employee, their job title, the reviewer, and the review period. Next comes a rating scale with every level defined, often a 5-point scale that runs from below expectations to outstanding. Then list the job-related competencies you will rate, for instance work quality, productivity, job knowledge, communication, teamwork, dependability, and initiative. The form should also look back at the prior period's goals and set new ones, leave room for the employee's self-assessment and the manager's comments, and include a development or training plan, an overall rating, and signature lines for both people. Word the signature line as an acknowledgment: signing shows the review took place and was talked through, which is not the same as agreeing with it. Job-related criteria and a clearly defined scale make the form fairer and easier to apply the same way every time.

What is the difference between a performance appraisal and a performance review?

There is no real difference in meaning; they describe the same process and document. Performance appraisal is the term used more often in British English, while performance review and employee evaluation are the more common American terms. The Oxford Advanced Learner's Dictionary treats them as synonyms, labeling performance review as both British and North American English and appraisal as especially British. Whichever label you use, the activity is the same: a manager looks back at how an employee performed over a period, rates competencies and goals, gives feedback, and sets goals for the next period. If you are a US small business, you can use whichever term your team is comfortable with; the forms on this page work the same regardless of what you call the process.

What rating scale should a performance appraisal use?

For most small businesses, a 5-point scale is a sound choice: for example, 1 = below expectations, 2 = needs improvement, 3 = meets expectations, 4 = exceeds expectations, and 5 = outstanding. SHRM reported in 2014 that appraisal systems most often use 3-level and 5-level scales. Whatever the number of levels, describe each one in a sentence anyone can follow, so two managers looking at the same work land on the same rating. Some businesses prefer a 3-point scale for its simplicity, especially in a probationary review, or a 4-point scale that removes the neutral middle option. Apply one scale to every employee in comparable roles, and tie every rating to a concrete example instead of a gut feeling. A scale with clear definitions is easier to apply fairly and easier to defend if someone questions a rating. This is general information, not legal advice.

How do I keep a performance appraisal fair and legal?

Rate what the employee actually did on the job, using criteria tied to the role, and hold everyone in similar positions to the same standards. Guidance from the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC) points the same way: explain the performance standards when a person is hired, apply them evenly when review time comes, and make sure race, color, religion, sex, national origin, age, disability, or other protected characteristics play no part in any rating. Back each rating with concrete examples instead of general impressions; the EEOC notes that facts like these can help employees see the reasoning behind a rating and help managers stay consistent. A structured form with defined competencies and a clear scale makes all of this easier. Keep every completed form on file, and word the signature line so the employee acknowledges the review without necessarily agreeing with it. This is general information, not legal advice; consult a qualified professional for your situation.

What is a self-appraisal form?

A self-appraisal form is a version the employee completes about their own performance, usually before the review meeting. It asks the employee to describe their accomplishments, note which goals went well or were missed and why, identify what they want to learn next, list any support or training that would help, and rate themselves on the same competencies and scale the manager uses. The self-appraisal gives the employee a voice in the review, surfaces accomplishments a busy manager may have missed, and makes the review meeting a two-way conversation rather than a one-sided verdict. It is especially useful for an annual review. This page includes a dedicated self-appraisal form alongside the manager-completed versions.

How often should a small business run performance appraisals?

Plan on one formal appraisal a year, often paired with a lighter mid-year check-in. Add a dedicated review at the end of a new hire's introductory period, which usually runs 30 to 90 days, according to SHRM. Annual reviews create a consistent record and a natural moment to set goals and discuss development and pay. That said, Harvard Business Review reported in 2016 that more than a third of US companies had abandoned traditional appraisals, and many organizations are shifting to more frequent, development-focused conversations so feedback is timely rather than saved up for one annual meeting. A practical small-business rhythm is a 90-day review for new hires, brief quarterly or mid-year check-ins, and one comprehensive annual appraisal. The key is consistency: pick a cadence, use the same forms, and actually hold the reviews on schedule. This is general information, not legal advice.

Do employees have to sign a performance appraisal form?

Asking for a signature is standard practice, though an employee who refuses to sign does not invalidate the appraisal. A well-designed form spells out what the signature means: the employee received the review and went over it with you, which is different from agreeing with every point. Institutional forms use the same acknowledgment clause; the review instructions at Georgia Southwestern State University, for example, say the employee's signature only acknowledges receipt of the evaluation. When an employee declines, write that on the form, for instance that the review was discussed and the employee declined to sign, and have a witness sign it. File the signed or annotated form so you keep a clear record that the review happened and was communicated, which matters if it later supports a pay, promotion, or employment decision. This is general information, not legal advice.

Make HR the easy part of running your business

Onboarding, e-signatures, training and core HR in one place. Up and running in 5 minutes.

  • 7-day free trial
  • No credit card required
  • Cancel anytime
4.7 on G2300+ companies trust FirstHR