FirstHR

How to Hire Remote Employees: A Practical Playbook for US Small Businesses

How to hire remote employees at a US small business. Sourcing, interviewing, multi-state compliance, I-9 remote verification, and Day 1 onboarding.

TL;DR
Hiring remote employees at a US small business takes five pre-hire decisions (remote structure, states, compensation, policy, async suitability), registration in each new state (income tax withholding where applicable, unemployment insurance, workers' comp), I-9 verification (in person, or by video for E-Verify employers), and structured onboarding. The biggest mistake is treating remote hiring like in-office hiring with a different address.
Category
Updated
Oct
27
2026
Reading time
18min

My first remote hire was a disaster of my own making. I found a great candidate, made the offer, and then realized I had no idea how to handle the compliance side. This guide is the playbook I wish I had back then, and it is built so you do not have to learn it the way I did.

That hire lived in a different state, and I had not registered there. I did not know what an I-9 alternative procedure was. I had no remote onboarding plan. The person started on a Monday, received a laptop on Wednesday, and spent their first week confused, unproductive, and probably regretting their decision.

The guide covers everything a US small business needs to hire remote employees: what to decide before posting the job, where to find candidates, how to interview remotely, the compliance layer that catches unprepared employers, the offer and paperwork process, and the Day 1 to Day 30 onboarding that determines whether your new hire stays. It is US-only and assumes you are hiring W-2 employees within the United States. If you are hiring internationally, you need an Employer of Record, and that is a different guide entirely.

I built FirstHR to solve the post-offer side of this process: e-signature for offer letters and policy acknowledgments, AI-generated onboarding plans, async training modules, and task workflows that give a remote hire the same structured first 90 days that an in-office hire gets. Sourcing runs through job boards, LinkedIn, or referrals, and FirstHR takes over when someone says yes.

Ryan Howard · First week
  • Sign the offer letter
  • Sign the employee handbook
  • Workplace Safety course
2/3
Onboarding
Run onboarding from one checklist
Tasks, documents to sign and courses for each new hire, sent with one launch.
Start free trial7-day free trial, no credit card

Why Hire Remotely in the First Place

For small businesses, hiring remotely unlocks three advantages: access to talent outside your local market, reduced overhead with no additional office space, and the ability to compete with larger employers on flexibility. That last one matters more than founders expect, because flexibility is the one benefit a small team can offer on exactly the same terms as a large one.

According to the Bureau of Labor Statistics (Beyond the Numbers, March 2025), 22.9% of people at work teleworked or worked at home for pay in the first quarter of 2024, up from 19.6% a year earlier. Remote work is now a structural part of how work gets done, not a pandemic experiment.

But remote is not the right answer for every role. Roles that require physical presence (retail, manufacturing floor, client-facing service), roles that depend on real-time collaboration with on-site teams, and roles where the founder does not have the management infrastructure to support a remote worker are all cases where hiring locally makes more sense. The decision should be based on the work, not the trend.

Tip
When Remote Is the Wrong Answer
If the role requires hands-on work with physical materials, daily in-person collaboration with an existing team, or direct customer contact at a specific location, hire locally. If the role is primarily computer-based, can be measured by output, and does not require real-time physical presence, remote works.

Five Decisions to Make Before You Post the Job

The five decisions are remote structure, state restrictions, compensation model, remote work policy, and async suitability (whether the role can run on each person's own schedule). Most founders post a remote job before settling them, and each open question creates problems later.

DecisionOptionsWhy It Matters
Remote structureFully remote / Hybrid / Remote within [state]Determines whether you need multi-state compliance. 'Remote within California' keeps you in one state. 'Fully remote US' means you register wherever the hire lives.
State restrictionsOpen to all states / Specific states onlyEach new state means new tax registration, unemployment insurance, and potentially workers' comp. Start with states where you are already registered.
Compensation modelSame pay regardless of location / Location-adjustedLocation-adjusted pay saves money but adds complexity. For most small businesses hiring one to three remote workers, one salary range regardless of location is simpler.
Remote work policyWritten policy / Informal understandingA written policy covering work hours, communication expectations, equipment, and expenses prevents confusion on Day 1. Does not need to be long.
Async suitabilityRole works async / Requires real-time overlapIf the role requires 6+ hours of overlap with a specific time zone, that limits your candidate pool. State it in the posting.

The most consequential decision is state restrictions. Hiring one remote employee in a new state triggers a series of compliance obligations: state income tax withholding registration where the state taxes wages, state unemployment insurance (SUTA) enrollment, and potentially workers' compensation coverage from an in-state carrier. Where they apply, these are legal requirements, not options, and they begin the moment the employee starts working in that state.

Hiring a remote team rather than one remote hire

If you set out to hire a remote team instead of a single person, the setup work multiplies. Every state on the roster is its own registration, its own unemployment account, and its own filing calendar, so hiring three people in three states costs roughly three times the administrative setup of one.

The practical move is to concentrate. Pick the two or three states you are already registered in, treat them as your hiring map for the year, and open a new one only when a candidate is clearly better than anyone available inside the map. Time zones deserve the same discipline, because a team spread across five of them shares only a few working hours each day.

The last thing that changes is what onboarding has to carry. With one remote hire you can improvise around a founder who answers questions all day. By the third or fourth, those answers have to live somewhere a new person can read them without asking, which is when the written 30-day plan further down this guide stops being optional.

See who is on track and who is stuck
Active Onboardings lists every new hire in progress. Late items are marked, so you see them without messaging anyone.

Writing a Remote Job Post That Filters Well

A remote job post needs three elements that a standard posting does not: the remote structure (fully remote, hybrid, or limited to specific states), time zone and overlap requirements, and equipment and workspace expectations. Including these three elements filters out candidates who are not a fit before they apply, which saves screening time.

Three phrases I now include in every remote posting: "This role is fully remote within [states or US]." "Core working hours are [X] to [Y] [timezone]. Outside of those hours, work is async." "We provide [laptop/stipend/nothing]. You are responsible for a reliable internet connection and a quiet workspace." In my own postings, those three phrases cut down the mismatched applications before anyone hit send.

What worked for me
I posted my second remote role as "fully remote, US-only" without specifying states. I got an excellent candidate in Hawaii. By the time I realized I needed to register in Hawaii for payroll, withholding, and unemployment insurance, the candidate had already accepted. It took two weeks to get everything set up, and the start date had to be pushed. Now I list specific states I am already registered in and add "other states considered on a case-by-case basis."
Nick AnisimovNick Anisimov, FirstHR founder

Where to Find Remote Candidates

The same sourcing channels work for remote roles as for in-office roles, with one addition: remote-specific job boards that attract candidates who are already set up for remote work and know what it requires.

ChannelBest ForRemote-Specific AdvantageHow You Pay
General job boards (sponsored posts)Broadest reach, all role typesA 'remote' location filter attracts high volumeDaily budget you set, and you stop paying the moment you pause the post
LinkedIn JobsProfessional and salaried rolesRemote filter plus passive candidate targetingSame daily-budget model, with the budget set on each individual job post
Employee referralsAll roles, highest qualityYour existing remote employees know other remote-ready peopleFree to run; the only cost is the bonus you choose to offer
We Work RemotelyTech, design, marketing, operationsPure remote audience, no in-office noiseFlat fee per posting, paid up front, for a fixed run length
FlexJobsProfessional roles, experienced remote workersEvery listing hand-screened, no ads or junk postsFree to employers; FlexJobs charges job seekers a subscription instead

For a small business hiring 1 to 3 remote employees per year, one general job board plus LinkedIn plus referrals covers most needs. Add one remote-specific board if the role is hard to fill or if you want candidates with proven remote experience.

Interviewing Remote Candidates: What to Look For

Interviewing remote candidates requires the same structured approach as in-person interviews (same questions, same order, scorecard). On top of that, evaluate four remote-specific skills: written communication (most remote work is async and text-based), self-direction (nobody is watching, so they need to manage their own time), proactive communication (they must surface problems, not wait to be asked), and comfort with ambiguity (remote environments have less implicit information than offices).

Run the interview on video with cameras on. This is the communication medium they will use daily. If the video call is choppy, disorganized, or difficult, that is useful information. Ask at least one question about their home workspace setup and one about how they have handled isolation or communication challenges in previous remote roles.

Tip
The Async Test
Before the final interview, give candidates a small, paid task ($50 to $150) that mirrors the actual work. Set a 48-hour deadline with no check-ins. How they approach the task (quality, communication, self-direction) tells you more about their remote readiness than any interview question. Pay everyone who completes it, whether you hire them or not.

The Compliance Layer Nobody Tells You About

Compliance is where remote hiring differs most from in-office hiring. Hiring a remote employee in a state where you are not yet registered as an employer triggers a chain of legal obligations. Ignoring them does not make them optional. It makes you non-compliant.

One employee in a new state changes your tax footprint

When you hire a remote employee in a new state, you must register for state income tax withholding in that state if it taxes wages (so you can withhold state taxes from their paycheck), enroll in that state's unemployment insurance program (SUTA), and potentially obtain workers' compensation coverage from an in-state carrier.

Some states require additional registrations. A payroll provider handles most of this, but you need to initiate the process before the employee's start date.

What this changes for hiring is the shortlist. Before you run a final interview with somebody in a state you have never employed in, you want to know whether an offer there is a week away or a month away.

The first tab below holds that answer: not the account numbers themselves, which belong in your multi-state payroll register, but the go/no-go decision and the lead time behind it. The second tab covers the per-hire side, where the new hire report and the state withholding form get logged with the date each was actually filed.

Pre-Offer State Clearance and New Hire Filing Log
ABCDEFGH
1StateWho already works thereSet up as an employer hereWorkers comp extended to this stateWeeks to get set up if notEarliest realistic start dateClear to make an offer hereChecked on
2Answer the last column before the final interview, not after the offer.
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11

Form I-9 for someone you may never meet in person

Form I-9 requires you, or an authorized representative acting for you, to examine the original identity and work authorization documents while the employee is physically present. There is one exception, and it is the only remote option. If you are enrolled in E-Verify (the federal online system that checks work authorization) and in good standing, you can use the Department of Homeland Security (DHS) alternative procedure: review copies, confirm the documents over live video, and retain legible copies.

The alternative procedure is permanent, not a temporary accommodation. DHS authorized it under a final rule effective August 1, 2023. Without it, someone has to see the originals in person: you meet the new hire yourself, or you designate an authorized representative (a notary, a librarian, or a friend of the employee) in the new hire's location to examine the documents and complete Section 2, the employer's part of the form.

The representative route fails in practice for one reason: the person doing you the favor has never seen the form before and nobody told them what they were agreeing to do.

The fix is written instructions in the envelope with the blank form; the designation and instruction sheet in the I-9 guide linked above is written for exactly that. Give them a return deadline a day earlier than your own, because the three business days run from the employee's first day of work and a slow mail run is not an extension.

FLSA applies the same to remote workers

The Fair Labor Standards Act (FLSA) treats remote hours the same as on-site hours. If the employee is non-exempt, meaning eligible for overtime, you track their hours and pay overtime for anything over 40 in a week. Department of Labor Fact Sheet 21 requires you to keep the hours worked each day and each week on file, and working from home changes none of that.

Exempt employees are the other half of the question. FLSA overtime rules do not reach them, but only if they clear both the salary and duties tests: $684 a week on a salary basis, plus the executive, administrative, or professional duties. Remote work has no bearing on either test.

Onboarding Templates
Sales Associate11 steps
Warehouse Foreman10 steps
Customer Service12 steps
Onboarding
Each new hire, set up in one go
Put tasks, documents to sign and courses into one plan, then send all of it with one launch.

The Offer Letter and the Paperwork

A remote offer letter includes everything a standard offer letter includes (role, compensation, start date, at-will status, contingencies) plus three remote-specific elements: the remote work arrangement (fully remote, with or without state restrictions), equipment and stipend policy, and any expectations about travel (quarterly team meetups, annual company retreat, client visits).

Send the offer via e-signature. Once accepted, begin pre-boarding immediately. For a remote hire, pre-boarding is even more critical than for an in-office hire because there is no "show up and figure it out" fallback. The new hire needs to receive equipment, complete paperwork, and understand the Day 1 plan before they start.

The remote new-hire paperwork checklist

DocumentDeadlineRemote-Specific Notes
Form I-9Section 1 on/before Day 1, Section 2 within 3 business daysDocuments examined in person, by you or an authorized representative in the employee's location; E-Verify employers in good standing may use the alternative procedure (video examination) instead
Form W-4Before first paycheckSame as in-office. Collected via e-signature.
State withholding formBefore first paycheckUse the state where the employee works (for a remote hire, usually their home state), not your HQ state
Direct deposit authorizationBefore first paycheckSame as in-office
Remote work agreementDay 1 or with offer letterCovers workspace requirements, equipment, expenses, communication expectations
Equipment receipt acknowledgmentWhen equipment shipsDocuments what was provided and return expectations at separation
State new hire reportWithin 20 days (varies by state)Filed in the employee's work state, unless you register with the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services as a multistate employer and send every report to one state where you have staff

Day 1 to Day 30: The Onboarding Part Most Founders Skip

Remote onboarding comes down to a written Day 1 agenda and a 30-day ramp plan, built before the hire starts. According to Gallup (August 2023), only 28% of exclusively remote employees strongly agree that they feel connected to their organization's mission and purpose, tying the record low that group set in 2011. That disconnection does not start at month six.

The drift starts on Day 1, when the new hire logs in and nobody is there, no schedule is waiting, and the implicit "ask the person next to you" support system is missing too. Deliberate remote onboarding closes that gap, and it closes it in the first week rather than the first quarter.

My Day 1 agenda for remote hires

8:00 AM
Welcome video call with founder
15 minutes. Camera on, informal. Confirm they have access to everything.
8:30 AM
IT setup verification
Walk through laptop, email, Slack, project tools. Troubleshoot anything broken.
9:00 AM
Company overview (async)
30-minute recorded video: who we are, what we do, how we work. They watch at their pace.
9:30 AM
Team introductions
15-minute video call with each team member they will work with directly. 3 calls maximum.
10:30 AM
Role walkthrough with manager
30 minutes. Review the 30-60-90 day plan. Clarify first-week priorities.
11:00 AM
Async training modules
Product training, tools training, security basics. Self-paced, tracked in onboarding platform.
12:00 PM
Lunch break (yes, schedule it)
Remote employees skip lunch on Day 1 because nobody told them to stop. Tell them.
1:00 PM
First task assignment
One real but low-stakes task they can complete by end of day. Proves systems work and builds confidence.
3:00 PM
End-of-day check-in with manager
15 minutes. How did it go? What is confusing? What do you need for tomorrow?

The structure matters more than the specific activities. A remote hire who logs in to an empty Slack channel and a vague "get set up and let me know if you need anything" message is already disengaging. A remote hire who logs in to a scheduled day with clear expectations and a real task to complete feels like part of the team.

The 30-day ramp plan

Week 1: orientation, tool setup, company overview, team introductions, first small task. Week 2: deeper training, first independent contribution, daily async check-ins. Week 3: independent work on real deliverables, check-ins taper to every other day. Week 4: formal Day 30 review against milestones, set goals for Days 31 to 60. The entire plan should be documented, shared with the new hire before Day 1, and tracked in your onboarding platform.

I built the AI onboarding wizard in FirstHR because building these plans by hand takes hours and most founders skip it. The wizard builds a role-specific onboarding plan from the position you are hiring for, with tasks, documents, and training modules laid out from pre-boarding through the first month and beyond, and that plan can be extended into a 30-60-90 plan.

A written plan like that is the difference between a remote hire who ramps in 30 days and one who is still confused at Day 60.

Mistakes I Made on My First Remote Hire

Moving too fast on the offer

I extended an offer before checking whether I was registered as an employer in the candidate's state. The registration took two weeks. The start date was pushed. The candidate nearly accepted another offer in the meantime. Now I check state registration status before the final interview.

Skipping the remote-specific reference check

I asked standard reference check questions. I did not ask: "How did this person perform in a remote or independent work environment? Were they proactive in communicating status, or did you have to chase them?" Those two questions would have surfaced a pattern that cost me three months.

Under-investing in the first week

I treated remote onboarding like in-office onboarding with a video call instead of a handshake. It is not the same. In an office, the new hire absorbs information passively: they overhear conversations, watch how people work, pick up culture from lunch and hallway interactions. Remote hires get none of that. Every piece of information must be delivered deliberately.

My first remote hire got a 30-minute welcome call and a "reach out if you need anything." They did not reach out. They quietly struggled for three weeks and then told me they were thinking about leaving. Now I build a full Day 1 schedule and a 30-day ramp plan before the person starts.

What worked for me
The single biggest improvement in my remote hiring process was building the Day 1 agenda and 30-day plan before posting the job. When I write the plan first, I write a better job description (because I know exactly what the person will do). I ask better interview questions (because I can test whether they can do the Day 30 deliverables). And the new hire arrives to a clear roadmap instead of a blank screen. The plan is the bridge between recruiting and retention.
Nick AnisimovNick Anisimov, FirstHR founder
Set up your next new hire in FirstHR
4.7 on G2
Offer LetterSigned
Welcome courseCompleted
Key takeaways
1Make five decisions before you post the job: remote structure, state restrictions, compensation model, remote work policy, and async suitability.
2One remote employee in a new state triggers unemployment insurance enrollment and, where the state taxes wages, withholding registration, plus possible workers' comp obligations, so check registration status before the final interview rather than after the offer.
3Remote I-9 verification still means examining the original documents in person, yourself or through an authorized representative in the employee's location, unless you are an E-Verify employer in good standing using the DHS alternative procedure.
4Every remote job post needs three elements a local post does not: remote structure and state eligibility, time zone and overlap requirements, and equipment and workspace policy.
5Interview for the four skills remote work actually demands, which are written communication, self-direction, proactive communication, and comfort with ambiguity, and use a paid async task to test them.
6Remote onboarding needs more structure than in-office onboarding, because the implicit information transfer of an office does not exist, so build the Day 1 agenda and the 30-day ramp plan before the hire starts.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I hire a remote employee in a state where my business is not registered?

Yes, but hiring in a new state triggers compliance obligations. You will likely need to open a state income tax withholding account and a state unemployment insurance (SUTA) account there. Some states also require you to buy workers' compensation from a carrier in that state. Processing time varies widely: a few states issue account numbers online within a day, others take several weeks, and the state tax filings for your first payroll need those account numbers. That is the reason to check the state before you agree to a start date rather than after. None of this means you need a physical office there. It means you need to register as an employer in that state, and a payroll provider can handle most of the filings for you.

Do I need an EOR to hire remote US employees?

No. An Employer of Record (EOR) is designed for hiring employees in countries where you do not have a legal entity. For hiring remote employees within the United States, you do not need an EOR. You register your business in the employee's state, set up payroll, and comply with that state's employment laws. EORs are useful for international hiring. For domestic remote hiring, standard employer registration is sufficient and far less expensive.

How is remote I-9 verification different?

By default it is not different: you or an authorized representative must examine the new hire's original identity and work authorization documents in their physical presence. For a remote hire, that means meeting the person yourself or designating a representative in their location, who can be any person you choose and does not have to work for you, to inspect the originals face to face and fill out Section 2 on your behalf. You stay liable for what the representative gets wrong. The one exception is for employers enrolled in E-Verify and in good standing, who may use the alternative procedure from the Department of Homeland Security (DHS): look over copies of the documents, confirm them with the employee on a live video call, and keep legible copies on file. The alternative procedure rests on a DHS final rule that took effect August 1, 2023, so it is permanent rather than a temporary accommodation.

What does it actually cost to hire one remote employee?

The fully loaded cost of a remote employee is close to what an in-office employee costs, and the multiplier comes from the same place. According to the Bureau of Labor Statistics Employer Costs for Employee Compensation survey (June 2026), private industry employers paid $46.89 an hour in total compensation, of which $32.82 was wages and $14.07 benefits, which puts the loaded cost at roughly 1.4 times pay. Legally required costs (employer FICA, the Social Security and Medicare tax, at 7.65%; federal and state unemployment taxes; and workers' compensation) are already part of that benefits figure and total $3.40 an hour, so do not add them on top. Remote-specific extras are budget decisions you set rather than fixed market rates: a home office stipend, equipment, and coworking access if you offer it. For the hiring side, SHRM's 2025 benchmarking puts the average cost per hire for nonexecutive roles at $5,475 in recruiting spend alone.

How do I onboard a remote employee I have never met in person?

The same fundamentals apply as in-person onboarding, but execution requires more intentionality. Collect the signed paperwork electronically before Day 1, and schedule the Form I-9 document review (in person, or by live video if you use the E-Verify alternative procedure) so Section 2 is finished within three business days of the start date. Ship equipment early enough that it arrives before the start date. Build a Day 1 schedule with video calls for introductions and a recorded company overview they can watch at their pace. Assign async training modules for product knowledge and tools. Create a 30-60-90 day plan with specific milestones. Schedule check-ins at Day 7, 30, 60, and 90. The structure matters more for remote hires because there is no desk neighbor to answer questions.

What should I include in a remote job posting?

A remote job posting needs everything a standard posting needs (title, responsibilities, qualifications, salary range) plus three remote-specific elements. First, the remote structure: say whether the job is fully remote, hybrid, or open only to candidates in certain states. Second, time zone and overlap: must the person be online during set hours, or can the work be done asynchronously, on each person's own schedule? Third, equipment and workspace policy: whether you provide equipment, offer a stipend, or expect the employee to supply their own. Spelling out all three lets poor-fit candidates drop out on their own, before anyone spends time on a screening call.

Is it legal to pay remote employees differently based on location?

Generally yes, location-based pay is legal in the United States. Many companies adjust compensation based on cost of living in the employee's location. However, you cannot pay differently based on protected characteristics (race, gender, age, etc.), and some states and cities have pay transparency laws that require disclosing salary ranges in job postings. If you use location-based pay, be transparent about it in the posting and consistent in application. The simplest approach for small businesses: set one salary range for the role and apply it regardless of location.

Do remote employees need workers' compensation insurance?

Usually, yes. Workers' compensation requirements apply to remote employees the same as in-office employees, and the requirement comes from state law rather than federal law. Many states require coverage from the first employee, several start only at three to five employees, and Texas and South Dakota leave it optional for most private employers. The coverage is typically based on the state where the employee works (their home state), not where your business is headquartered. A remote hire in a new state may therefore mean arranging coverage there as well. Rates are generally lower for remote office work than for physical labor.

Make HR the easy part of running your business

Onboarding, e-signatures, training and core HR in one place. Up and running in 5 minutes.

  • 7-day free trial
  • No credit card required
  • Cancel anytime
4.7 on G2300+ companies trust FirstHR